Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: And Ye Shall Receive - Page 1 of 4
megculber
2009-12-04 . chapter 1
I'm love this ending but I'm not quite sure I undrestand it, Please tell me if I've gotten this wrong: Caspian DID marry Susan, so Susan was the star's daughter the whole time?
Don't mean to be nosey but I was having trouble wrapping my head around this all.
Barnabus III
2009-10-18 . chapter 1
That was very well done
ilikepie2013
2009-07-24 . chapter 1
WOW. that was an absolutely fantastic story. answered many questions, and the quality was superb. well done, VERY well done!
shllybkwrm
2009-07-22 . chapter 1
The end of Prince Caspian was so sad, and I'm so glad you wrote this fic - it was really lovely :).
Saffygirl
2009-03-08 . chapter 1
Cool story!
Apakoha
2009-01-27 . chapter 1
Interesting and well-told, but I didn't like it. It just looks like wish fulfillment to me. Call me a purist or what-have-you, but this didn't keep with the books at all. Sure, with what was explained in the books, it could have happened, but since the only thing we hear is what the Friends of Narnia tell us, it just seems like this went behind Lewis' back just because Susan and Caspian were cute in the movie.
LegacyOfThePheonix
2009-01-07 . chapter 1
(Kagumi:) Do I really have to say it? All right,yes, I do: Anne, you did beautifully, again. This is a good piece, and heartfelt. And it fits, so triple points to you, dear.
arnoldthefemalepurplepygmypuff
2008-12-21 . chapter 1
since i havent read the books, some things went right over my head, but... this story is amazing. and FINALLY, a happy ending for the couple.
MouseyCat
2008-08-28 . chapter 1
*squees*

WUV IT!

Wuv it, wuv it, wuv it!

*dances around*

You sneaky lady, you. :D
bedlamandbroomsticks
2008-08-23 . chapter 1
I think, of all those that provide a solution to the Susan question, this is one of the best answers.
Heidi
2008-07-21 . chapter 1
Very lovely! I've been wondering how they'd address the Susan issue if they ever get to the Last Battle. To be honest, I kind of hope they throw the book to the four winds and bring Susan back with the others! It always seemed so snarky and misanthropic of Lewis.
Dracis Tran
2008-07-08 . chapter 1
Well done, as is your usual :).

An interesting thought to answer the Question of Susan... but I don't like it (Sorry).

Lewis once said: "The books don't tell us what happened to Susan. She is left alive in this world at the end, having by then turned into a rather silly, conceited young woman. But there's plenty of time for her to mend and perhaps she will get to Aslan's country in the end... in her own way."

...I think she falls and is redeemed. In that way, she becomes my favorite character in the whole series, even if her redemption is offscreen. I also think it's important that it's possible for one to fall and be redeemed. I wish he had made it more clear... such as in a spin off novel, or even making it a main-sequence novel as to Susan's grief (for even as silly as she was, she would grieve her family's death). But we're all Susan in a way; we need to be writing that story ourselves.

Thanks for the thought though. I love reading any answer to the Question of Susan, and yours certainly has merit.
Amanthya
2008-07-07 . chapter 1
VERY well-thought-out, original, and in keeping with the spirit of the books. Even though I am picky and think to myself--but Aslan said she couldn't come back--this doesn't feel wrong to me. LOVE IT!
intastella burst
2008-06-29 . chapter 1
That was just . . . breathtaking. Wonderful reconcilation of bookverse and movieverse. Oh, if only this were canon . . . when I "got" the ending tears literally sprung to my eyes. Amazing work.
Morgaine of the Fairies
2008-06-19 . chapter 1
Aw. A very nicely done reconciliation of book and movie canon as far as The Susan Question (which has always bothered me) is concerned, with some extrapolation on the Susan/Caspian matter as well. At first, that invented relationship in movie canon bothered me, but fic like this makes me like it more and more. Thanks for a wonderful read!
Return to Top