wow! this was such a great story!! John was sweet. Sam was so cute with his rebellious side! and dean ... haha! gotta love them!
Good job!

it was a good chapter thank you

yeah ive always wondered what john did when he noticed his journal missing... i like that sam made a deal that dean wouldnt get spanked for the gifts LOL

Huh I'm not sure Sammy deserved that. John should have told him about his secrets, how could Sam have possible understood the importance of the journal if he didn't know what was in it? Poor Sammy, he always seems to draw the short stick.

What a wonderful story! I thoroughly enjoyed reading it! I'm glad that John talked to Sam about the journal and was willing to answer Sam's questions.

Yup, I could totally see it going down this way-John weary and sad but still needing to keep a rebellious Sam in line. Great job!