 ichixichigo 2009-06-20 . chapter 1Aww~!
This made me tear up a little.
;__; |
 SecretSnow 2008-10-22 . chapter 1You made me cry...I really like this fic but you made me cry! I think I would like to see this continued. It was really very very good i I loved it. |
 xfacexthisx 2008-06-19 . chapter 1That was really good. The entire thing was really sad. Poor Hughes and poor Ed. I feel sorry for both of them. I'm sure that Hughes would forgive Ed, if they were ever to meet again, in the afterlife that Ed barely believes in.
Anyways, great job. =) |
 Took-Baggins 2008-06-19 . chapter 1holy crap, that was absolutely heartbreaking! and SO well written! great job!! |
 radcat38 2008-06-15 . chapter 1Nice Father's Day story. Poor Ed...he could have included Al but I think Ed needed to do this by himself. His guilt issues. Maes was a second father to the boys just like Mustang. Maes was the good father and Mustang is the father you fight with. Ed had a good relationship with Maes and I am glad he got to honor him. Maybe Mustang was really trying to protect the boys when he lied to them about Maes or maybe he just could not bring himself to say outloud that Maes was dead. Our relationships can get so complicated and in the FMA world complicated does not even cover it. That world gives new meaning to complicated. Thanks for the story. Hope Ed feels slightly better. Maes would understand the humor behind the rank remark...he would have understood. I also liked the end of the anime episode where Maes stands at the station and waves good bye to Ed and only Ed sees him. Ed is mystified and thinks he imagined it. I thought that end was bittersweet but am glad Maes said goodbye to Ed. Nice rememberance of Maes...thanks. |
 Tia Ordona 23 2008-06-15 . chapter 1Wow...this was absolutely beautiful. The mentions of the friendship that Ed, Hughes, and Mustang shared, the guilt that accumulated on Ed, the different flowers to represent the occasion (I love flowers |
 jenelric 2008-06-15 . chapter 1Aww, that was so awesome!! You expressed Ed's emotions and character perfectly! That whole scene was absolutely perfect and definitely something that would've happened in the manga.
You did an amazing job! Fantastic work!! |
 Cold-Foxx 2008-06-15 . chapter 1That was terribly sad, but heartwarming in a way.
I really enjoyed the ending, as well as the scene with Edward and the clerk.
Good job! |