Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A lullaby for you - Page 1 of 3
TrucyWright15
2008-11-09 . chapter 13
Too sweet and lovely^^!
Great work!^^
Jestry
2008-10-07 . chapter 13
Huh.
Not bad, I guess.

You might want to befriend spellcheck. I think you used their instead of there in one of the chapters, and you spelled Epilogue wrong...

Overall, I mean. There were some really nice parts that made me warm and fuzzy. But they don't connect, and it feels a little discombobulated.

Hmm. I can't see Neku being all assertive and calling Shiki pet names like "Angel" or so willingly proclaiming his love. It's just, not really part of his character. In my opinion at least. And Primrose; you made this big intro about her, but then in the end, she wasn't really part of the plot at all. I feel like you could have directed our attention to somewhere else more meaningful. Not much character development either. It's like, Shiki and Neku feel the same way for each other, but now that they have their obstacles out of the way, they are suddenly together. Try making their relationship more dynamic. It wouldn't hurt if they got mad at each other a few times. Real people do that you know.

I hope I'm not totally bashing your fic. Because I /do/ commend you for finishing it and sticking with it all the way through. And there /are/ some really nice things that happened. You have nice description and diction overall, it you just need to make the separate parts flow into an actual story.

Keep it up! :D
Rie Mizuki
2008-09-30 . chapter 13
Wow! Nice! But, don't you think it was a bit short for an epilogue? Nah, don't worry about details. Thanks for continue it to the end. This is a great story!! ^^
Plushietiger
2008-09-29 . chapter 13
Aww such a sweet way to end the story. Cute epilogue and so sweet
The Legendaerie LT
2008-09-09 . chapter 12
That was kind of... random and odd. Um... yeah.

Yay Joshua!!
REDskies
2008-09-09 . chapter 12
Simply awesome story.
Some of your spelling and grammar could use some work, but other than that, its really really great. Good job.
Rie Mizuki
2008-09-05 . chapter 12
Honestly, I love the plot at this final chapter. But again, is it a bit too short? Hmm, maybe it's just my feeling. Nah, don't worry about details. You're still done great enough! ^^
Plushietiger
2008-09-04 . chapter 12
Great finale but i feel like maybe you shouldn't have left on the note of Shiki slapping him, and showing no sweetness between them. Still a great ending though! :3
Rie Mizuki
2008-09-04 . chapter 11
Ow, so sweet! But, don't you think it was a bit short? Nah, don't worry, you're still good anyway! Keep up the good work!! ^^
The Legendaerie LT
2008-09-02 . chapter 11
Yay. Toasts and updates. And... toasts. Yummy.

((I have nothing really to say))
jolteonforever
2008-09-02 . chapter 11
Hey this fic is so cool!
You're an awesome writer!
And you make it so cute! xD
Plushietiger
2008-09-01 . chapter 11
Go Shiki! Thats right you don't have to be little mis perfect daughter anymore XD Primrose is cool and i love her hobby (kicking vending machines to see if a drink would come out) Update soon :3
Recollection
2008-08-19 . chapter 9
This is just what I was looking for.
Neku and Shiki are my favorite pairing ever.
The Legendaerie LT
2008-08-16 . chapter 9
Ah nos... so sad! I loe it though.. continues?
Plushietiger
2008-08-13 . chapter 9
Good chapters! update soon :3
Return to Top