Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Yesterday Once More
nobody's
2008-07-06 . chapter 1
It's nice to read a story dedicated to Shirley.
It's really sad that she had to die in the end and in a such cruel way. Reminds me of Euphemia's bitter momemt.
Men are idiots, pf... they shouldn't have left her alone in tne first place.
Theos Amneos
2008-07-03 . chapter 1
:P Well you certainly know how to keep my interest. Very nice Shirley-centric fic; it was quite impressive how far you managed to get with just 'deductive reasoning'. I agree that Shirley's a pretty bright girl (she's still in a Student Council after all, eccentricities aside), so I very much hope she'll have taken the time to think about some of the things you've mentioned in the actual show itself.

Here are three minor nitpicks, though. First of all, Shirley's father was actually a civilian, not a soldier. He was one of the people who didn't properly evacuate, and thus got caught in the landslide. Second, on the extent of Shirley's prejudice against the Japanese: seeing as Shirley was the first person at Ashford besides Lelouch to try to befriend Suzaku, she seems quite open to me. That attitude doesn't necessarily contradict with what you have here, but I thought I'd bring it up nonetheless. As for the third nitpick, I found the statement that 'Lelouch had the power to make anyone obey him' a bit of a jump, as Shirley's single experience with Lelouch's geass seems like too little to make that deduction.
CherriDeulle
2008-07-01 . chapter 1
one of the best shirleys ever and i wonder what will happen in ep 13 O.o? but i was really happy that they are finally a couple! but there is an ominous feeling i have that she will probably...die...
Jarr Jar
2008-06-30 . chapter 1
very good, best portrayl of shirley I've ever seen!
Return to Top