Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Closing Ranks - Reviews: Page 1 of 3

Slidell
2008-07-21
ch 1,
abuseThis was great. I love the way you picked it up from where that episode ended. I was like...uh, it just cut off. But you did it justice and then some, thank you!
sg-1fanintn
2008-07-20
ch 1,
abuseSince it had to happen, I would have really liked to see it happen this way. Much more satisfying than what we got on-screen. Very much in character for all.

Thanks for this!
Suse B
2008-07-17
ch 1,
abuse:D

Nice, nice job.

I usually (well, on screen) have issues with Vala. I liked her in this.

Nice and team-y. Thanks.
Rac80
2008-07-17
ch 1,
abusewonderful story. a much needed tag and exactly what I would ahve expected to happen. Oh I can see vala as the practical joke queen harassing the stink out of woolsey! ;) well written and a lot of fun!
Knight of Avalon
2008-07-16
ch 1,
abuseGood job.

It's nice to see all of SG-1. And Jack's "You didn't screw up" speech was great.

Yep, Mr. Weasle is going to get one *heck* of a reception.
jz9
2008-07-16
ch 1,
abuseThe last scene hurt. Period. This story does not make it hurt less, but I loved it still. Loved Vala. Loved the team support. Loved the Carter/Jack exchange. I imagine it will continue to eat at Carter as days go by, but she will survive.
Karigan Wolfshead
2008-07-16
ch 1,
abuseAwesome. I was so hurt when I heard Carter was reassigned, and Amanda Tapping, not on Stargate! Anyway, nice story, and I wish that it could be reality, and Woolsey really get a icy reception, but in dreams...
Ann-sgcfan
2008-07-16
ch 1,
abuseI thought the way they ended S&R was horrible, especially when Amanda told them before they even started breaking stories for season5 that she wouldn't be there! It was a horrible send off to a character and actor who has been on the show 11 years. :( Sorry for the little rant.

I really liked how you wrote the fix for the ending! The reaction from Vala was cute and a fitting reaction for SG-1 as well. Even including Jack was a great touch... I would think the IOA had to inform him since he is over the SGC and Atlantis. Very good fic :~)
gater62
2008-07-16
ch 1,
abuseLovely episode tag! I can really see this happening!
sammie77
2008-07-16
ch 1,
abuseLoved it - haven't seen S&R yet - not sure I really want to if their doing Sam that way...Loved the story, though!
Manda's Girl aka Charlie
2008-07-16
ch 1,
abuseThankyou for writing this! It definitely helped salve someof my angry feelings over the way Carter's departure was handled. :)
debcole
2008-07-15
ch 1,
abuseOh my gosh, you expressed perfectly my exact thoughts! I couldn't believe that Woolsey told her as soon as she had come through the gate. What a weasel! I felt so bad for Sam.
macisgate
2008-07-15
ch 1,
abuseThat was the best. Really awesome job. Going on the favorites list for sure. Thanks so much!
Bunnylass
2008-07-15
ch 1,
abuseOh, you have no idea how much i needed this!

It was fantastic and so perfect.

Perfect beginning, middle and end...

Especially the end ;D

Thank you : )
vball2003
2008-07-15
ch 1,
abuseOkay, this makes me feel a little better about the episode. I couldn't believe they ended it that way! I was soo mad. This would have helped though, a nice little scene with SG1 and Jack :)
Thanks!
~Danielle
Return to Top