Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Love Unknown
LaRosedesVents 10/27/10 . chapter 1
Thank you for your review :-) You have so many stories! I love the HG/SS pairing...this was nice, an insight into another side of Hermione. If only it were easy to tell people how we felt!
Valmarien 3/31/10 . chapter 1
You are right. The pain of the unsaid is really heartbreaking. Thank you for this story and a hopeful ending.
LadyScarlettO'Hara 3/6/10 . chapter 1
Awesome, but sad...
hermoine snape 7/5/09 . chapter 1
an wonderful one shot! five Starz
Daughters of Night 11/28/08 . chapter 1
Nice moral. Good story, but I just can't see Snape and Herimone together. But HA! You're special. This is the first story I've ever read with Snape and Herimone. Yay, you!
excessivelyperky 8/24/08 . chapter 1
Well, this is an improvement over canon where nobody even bothered to check Snape's pulse in the Shack. A pity that Snape never knew that _anyone_ loved him.
Siobhan 8/23/08 . chapter 1
Aww! Loved it, so cute!

Really sweet, made me tear up a little. Nice.

Great job.
Shining Nova 8/22/08 . chapter 1
I was referred to this fic by someone on my forum, and I've gotta say... they had a reason to recommend your fic.

In short, it needs work, babe. Things that need improvement...

Grammar

-Grammar was a little funny in particular places, like here...

/I could use the time turner that I had kept from when I was in my third year at Hogwarts, but [would it be worth it in the end, ]because I do not know If he even loved me at all./

'Would it be worth it' is more of a question than a statement. Instead, you could have phrased it like this...

/I could use the time turner that I had kept from when I was in my third year at Hogwarts, but it wouldn't be worth it in the end, because I do not know If he even loved me at all./

Much better. Another place...

/The last time that I was able to go to his grave was my last time./

This comment... doesn't quite read well. It sounds as though you're repeating yourself. What you could have done was...

/The last time I was able to go to his grave.../ and you could have stated what happened during that last time. Last place...

/My love Severus, and me finally knew how we felt for each other./

'Severus and me' is incorrect. 'Severus and I' is what you wanted.

Punctuation

-A few punctuation mistakes...

/In the days that went by I had dreams of him, and me together./

Comma goes after 'by,' but the comma after 'him' is unnecessary. Another spot...

/As the years went by I would go, and visit his grave, and put some flowers on it every Sunday./

Comma after 'go' is incorrect.

Plot

-While I loved the moral of the fic... I don't think you could have executed this as well as you could have. It lacked... could be because of details, of exposition, of lack of character development. Either way, I feel that the plot could have been a lot better.

Final Comments

-You aren't a bad writer, but you have a few kinks to work out. Don't take that as discouragement; I want everyone to write the best they can. And I know you have it in you.

-Nova.
anon 8/15/08 . chapter 1
"The last time that I was able to go was my last time."

?
snowtigress-27 8/13/08 . chapter 1
That was very nice, very sweet. I was kind of sad, but then you had a happy ending!

Hmm, this is odd. You read somehting of mine, I read something of yours. I look at your other reviewer. It's debjunk, one of my own faithful reviewers. hee-hee. kind of funny.
debjunk 8/13/08 . chapter 1
Great moral, and a sad story. But they found happiness eventually and that will last for eternity. ;)
Return to Top