Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Guitars and Stars - Page 1 of 3
ScarletGrace45 9/1/11 . chapter 9
Sickinely sweet keep it up!
A Heart on my Hand 10/21/09 . chapter 9
It's almost been a year. You mean I'm NEVER going to findout what happened? WHY are you so cruel?
Kenwoody 1/12/09 . chapter 9
Before I start this, let me just say that I have been a literary editor for four years now so if any of this comes out wrong, blame the editting gene.

Okay, first off, I loved it. You have a clear, distinct voice that you keep in tact incredibly well. Not to mention you bring entire new dimensions to the characters such as Sokka plays guitar, and Aang despises when people litter. This is what makes an amazing writer is that they know how to add pizzazz to a generic character.

The one thing that confused me a bit was the conversations with themselves. If you could specify that, that would be very effective. I sometimes do it in my stories, though i don't think I'm an amazing writer.

Next, the dialogue is very good and funny, though there are some awkward moments, like when you have a character stumbling over words or stuttering.

One question is why did Toph suddenly become concerned about college at 2:30 am? I would think that you would want to build that up a bit.

Next thing on the agenda... KATAANG ALL THE WAY AND I DON'T KNOW WHETHER OR NOT I'D CONTINUE TO READ THIS IF YOU CHOSE ZUTARA BECAUSE THE TOKKA IS GREAT BUT I'M NOT SURE IF IT'S ENOUGH TO BALENCE OUT THE ZUTARA!

Now that my shipping spazz is over I wanted to say great job, and this is very good. Update soon. Write on.
jellydonut14 12/24/08 . chapter 9
What? Who’s that! Get out of my mind! Lol, love that line. Update soon.
AvatarAiris 12/18/08 . chapter 9
hahaha :D i just have to say that i love the

fact that Sokka is starting to have his subconcious

talk to him just like Toph X) hehehe, at one point

when Sokka can't take it anymore you should use his

line "My brain! It has a mind of it's own!" from the

Puppetmaster ;P

and awesome idea, stirring up some drama with Zutara

in this one, too ;) hehehe, i can't wait to see in what

form the guys come back from the camping trip in :P

haha! Keep it up! _b
TwilightGD 12/13/08 . chapter 9
hehe, i couldn't keep a straight face when Toph was telling aang about liking sickling romantic things. Just imagining sokka doing something for Toph was making me laugh.

Should be fun to see Sokka try and teach Toph how to play. And the new drama from Katara and Zuko really is a page turner.

Write on
Haru-yurami 12/12/08 . chapter 9
OMG THE TENSION! Zutara or Kataang? Then the tokka, sokka has a great idea if it works out lol. But keep up the great work buddy!
JESUSFREAK-And-Proud-Of-It 12/8/08 . chapter 9
oh the TENSION is right! Man, I'm practically shaking with anticipation from that ending! Nice job on the chap, I love the Sokka and talking to himself bit...I've actually posted a story like that called Inner Conflict, but it's in Katara's POV...with Aang. Naturally. I think everyone has some inner voice (or more than one) that are there pestering them before they make every decision...even if it's just whether and what to eat in the morning.

"Eat Cereal!"

"No, oatmeal!"

"Cereal's better!"

"Oatmeal's healthier!"

"Get a life, no one cares about 'healthy!' anymore!"

"Willing to bet?"

"Bring it on!"

...

Am I the only one who does this? I'm willing to bet I'm not! :D
zutarababe 12/8/08 . chapter 9
wow... i hope this is zutara! i cant remember the summary so... yea..
Calysra 12/7/08 . chapter 8
Since the button is, in fact, RIGHT THERE, I figured I'd give in and actually write a review.

I really like this story. I liked the original one that this one is based off of, as well. Figured I'd let you know.

You do a really good job at keeping the characters in character while modernizing them. And Toph, in character when she's being mushy? For real? You handle it amazingly well, and I love reading your style. Switching between PoVs keeps it interesting, too.
xXsocXx 12/7/08 . chapter 8
OMG this story is so good, keep it up. I LOVE YOU MANDI(TORUH)!
TwilightGD 12/5/08 . chapter 8
wow, what a let down for Toph. After fighting herself and confessing, he falls right to sleep.

This was a heartwarming chap. Toph's fear of losing Sokka to College is truly realistic and I was glad you took this road. it is an issue they have to face, but i don't think our favorite meat-head will let us down.

Write on
JESUSFREAK-And-Proud-Of-It 11/29/08 . chapter 8
Yes, that button is VERY handy. I wish readers would use it more often. It's not like it takes an enormous amount of effort...

Anyway, nice chapter. Ooh...I sense a Toph vs. Katara middle-of-the-dang-night-why-are-you-even-bothering-with-a-argument coming! Whoo! Way to create suspense...you're way good at that!
zutarababe 11/29/08 . chapter 8
haha... sokka slept... xD
AvatarAiris 11/22/08 . chapter 7
gah! i can't beleive i've missed so

much of IHCS's sequel for so long X(

i'm still kicking myself for losing this fic :(

but at least i've found it again, hehe '

anywho... whoohoo! i am really loving this camping

trip sequel :D especailly the chapter when Toph, Sokka,

and Zuko actually called the Sozin Cable Co. XP

seriously an awesome funny scene _b

plz update again! i am really hoping to read more

of this awesome fic real soon :D
41 found: Page 1 .. 3 Next »
Return to Top