Oh word...that was amazing! This one is definitely going on my favs list, I love it!

As Always,

Joee

Great story! Loved the whole t-shirt thing. Definetly Dean.

-Spark

I'm not sure how I haven't found this story until now but I'm sure glad I did. I have a fascination with the ocean and shipwrecks and thought this was just wonderful. Interestingly, right when I started reading it The Mary Ellen Carter came up on my play list. I found that to be wonderfully fitting. :o) Anyway great story. Thanks for writing.

I thoroughly enjoyed this story:-) I appreciate the fact that you clearly put a lot of thought and research into your stories - it shows. I loved the self-sacrificialness (?) of the brothers and enjoyed the twist of the ghosts of Tommy's crew helping to save them. The scene with Dean on the raft and Sam in the water was remarkably reminiscent of a similar scene in the movie Titanic - did you have that in mind when you wrote this? It worked very well here and I loved both Sam and Dean's unwillingness to let go of the other. Great story;)

Wow, great! DD

You are a great writer I liked the story

Kisses and see ya next o/

Rosetta

Loved the characterization and the brotherly banter! This could have totally been an episode...too bad it didn't have more chapters, though ;-)

Brilliant grasp of the characters and an amazing story, I just couldn't stop reading it. It could have quite easily of been an episode. Yay!

What a great situation to put the boys in to offer some great brotherly fluff! Awesome story and you told it so well!

I love the way you portray the relationship between the brothers. Just the right amount of brotherly love without going overboard (get it...overboard).

And the idea of Dean letting Sam play in the 'big brother sandbox' was just brilliant.

The story was well thought out, exciting, and kept me on the edge of my seat from the very beginning. I'm working my way through all of your stories now.

Thank you so much for sharing.

AWW god! i loved what happened to Sam- the shoulder, bless him and the hyperthermia, you really do write the brothers so perfectly ;)

this was awesome! amazingly awesome :)

thanks hun!

me gusta xD

I like a good casefile/adventure-this was great. I loved the interaction between Sam and Dean.

Okay, I'm gonna come right out and say it..it freakin SUCKS that this was only 3 chapters! XP God, it was so good, this is one of the few stories that I would've liked to have been drawn out. ;D I absolutely loved this story, just so you know! Hey, have you ever seen the movie, "The Mist"? Cuz, you should totally right a SPN fic going along those lines. You'd be so good at it! ;P

I have always enjoyed stories of the sea. Add the boys, some great action, and a dose of whumpage, and you have a wonderful tale! This was creative, and so well done. It would make a great episode. I love the sacrifices of both Sam and Dean, the way they work together to survive. And the t-shirt was a really nice touch. :) Great job! Thanks so much!

AJ

Hey there!

Did I already gave a review here? Who cares...*smiles*

Well...I really like this story!First of all I was so looking for a season2!story, 'cause season4!boys are so hard to watch...You know what I mean I think. And S2!dean ist so cool and sweet and...Houh, I love it. And your Sam who plays in the sandbox of the Great Big Brother is pretty cool and awesome. And so is Dean, who threw himself over Sam and then his back...and his head...*outsch* I love hurt!dean. Duh.

Loved your detailed description of the night in the ocean, all that fog and the water and Sam searching for Dean, all pitch black and so on. And this rope (when it first touched Sams legs I was like ' No! WTF! That's just f*ing scary!). And I loved the ghosts who saved our beloved boys. It was all a little creepy but definetly so awesome :) :) :)

Oh - and Dean on this gadget and Sammy in the water, their strong hold on each other: I was SO thinking of Titanic...*lol**rofl* Liked your story more, 'cause the boys are much cooler than Jack and Rose (but I like them too)...and yeah, well...

There was so much angst and it was wonderfull and spooky, and so funny ("We were wearin’ nothing but blankets and birthday suits" - *LOL*)-So, I love your story!

Greetings from germany,

Kritty