Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Say Goodnight and Goodbye
mysterypoet66
2008-10-04 . chapter 1
It's sweet and funny and yet haunting. You've really fleshed out DoctorDonna in a way that makes sense. Thing 2 as well. Delineating them as themselves, while clearly painting in what the fusion means.
Mira-Jade
2008-09-02 . chapter 1
That was great! Really a missing scene I'd like to have seen. ;)
NewDrWhoFan
2008-09-01 . chapter 1
So FANTASTIC! Absolutely wonderful, and so Donna!

So much, like fifteen times, better than my own little "before Bad Wolf Bay" interlude.

Poor, poor Donna, but I love how sure she is that Rose'll be happy with her tailor-made Doctor :)
Suils Saifir
2008-08-31 . chapter 1
Gyah! You made me cry! I remembered her 'dying' and gah you had to prolong it! But in a very good way! Amazing, you ARE Russell T Davies aren't you?
Sina xx
Clio83
2008-08-29 . chapter 1
"Marinating in that creepy hand-aquarium, I’d imagine" - quite possibly the funniest line i've ever read in a doctor who fic!

This story was brilliant on just about every level. It was a wonderful little Doctor/Donna moment which perfectly captured their sibling type relationship, it was a poignant reminder of Donna's sad ending, it was a spot on insight into Doctor 2 and how he feels about the Rose situation and it even had the original idea of Donna sharing the Doctor's memories. I will stop gushing now, but I really really liked it (incase I didn't make that clear :))
lyin'
2008-08-29 . chapter 1
oh my god, i LOVED this. this might be my favorite post-Journey's End fic I've found (and everyone knows they're enough of them, i'm contributing to the influx myself) but this was so, so perfect, i ate up every line, and plus, it's a moment no one else has done a take on that i've seen, so, bonus points for originality, and this was great. perfectly characterized Donna, from Handy! to 'You're like a Chia Pet, just add Donna' (probably the best description of Ten II out there). the take on what's about to happen is great, i like how you have blue-suit knowing what's coming, Donna's emotions and the flashes of memories are dead-on and really this is so awesome- it's hysterical and at the same time angsty because we know what's coming and you get the Donna - Doctor dynamic so perfectly. everything i loved about series 4, crammed into this oneshot, really- smashing job, thanks so much for the read! :D
Return to Top