How novel. A Butler-bashing fic. Bravo on your originality.

Ahaha, You're so funny.
They both have an uncanny knack for talking while running don't they?

This is hilarious! Well done for writing such a fantatsic crossover.
It is a bit silly the way some people seem to think the Phantom if Gerard Butler. Some 'Phans' don't even know that his name is Erik, or that it's based on a book! How stupid!

Anyway, this is a brilliant little oneshot, thank you so much for writing it!

Melanie.

One little flaw: "Il Muto" is not a real opera and would not have been located in the Opera Garnier.

Too funny! LOL!

Oh, that was wonderful! I loved the dialogue between them - the quick humor and great one linders. Loved where Rose stole the screwdriver - and the 300 reference. *sigh*

As one of those 'shallow' PoTO phans, I have to say that I enjoyed this very much. ;)

Absolutely hysterical! I loved it!

Hysterically funny... as a "rabid fangirl" of both the Phantom and the Doctor... wow- that was crazy and adorable and it made me laugh out loud- which I've always thought of as the highest sort of praise.
Warmest regards,
K.S.

I'm here. Late, but here.

Okay here we go. Style: Wonderful. I love the dialogue only approach, it fits, and the quality of your writing never has me doubting who is speaking. It's hard to write without describing emotions or facial expressions, but you've done it. I can so imagine the Doctor's annoyance and Rose rolling her eyes. Oh, and you had the Doctor use the word 'fangirl'. Life. Is. Perfect.

On your subtle pointing the finger at the more shallow of the Phans, you suceeded. The first time I met just a plain GerryPhan, I wanted to slap the twit when she said she didn't know who Erik was. Eugh.

Then the ending. Spartans? 300? Yeah baby! Erik + a six pack and minus the scars = totally Gerry love.

Thanks. Here you have one happy fangirl.

Next episode: The Doctor takes Rose to the HMS Titanic, where she expects to see Leonardo DiCaprio. Much to her disappointment...

*snicker, giggle, falls over laughing* Oh that's good.
And gosh dangit, henna stings! *looks at kit bought from AC Moore* *grumble*
Nice. Keep writing!

Very funny. It does well with just the dialogue. Nice job.

Oh, that is too cute!