Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: The Greatest Gift - Page 1 of 15
One Is Not Amused 4/6/12 . chapter 18
'Scarlett remembered she was in the middle of her pregnancy with Bonnie. The curse of morning sickness had passed. Rhett had awakened especially early and sat gently running his fingers over her cheek until she also woke up. Then he rained kisses upon her face, lips and breasts, all the while caressing her swelling abdomen, the cradle of their unborn child. He pulled her onto her side and entered her, calling her name softly.'

I started crying when I read the above quote. It was so beautifully written and so beautifully realised that I couldn't help but. I've spent most of the night reading this fantastic story (I should be revising for my A Levels, but meh, it can wait) and I honestly don't know how to form a coherent review, it's so wonderful. So I'm sorry that this is short - I know everyone likes a lengthy review - but just wow. That's really all I can say. You're so brilliant at writing human emotions. I love this. Again: wow.
nostalgia859 2/20/12 . chapter 18
It has been a ling time since I cried reading a story and certainly never with a fanfic but your writing was absolutely moving . In one word this was beautiful. Everything about this tale was so real and how I really think their lives would end. You managed to relinquish their love without betraying the reality if this doomed characters . Other than Rhett's liaison with Manet and degas , I found it so believable . Even the "French woman " , though Dying was too good for her. The aging Scarlett was changed yet the same bullheaded child. Really beautiful work and though I know you finished this story years ago , I believe it to be worth even much more reviews
HelenSES 2/5/12 . chapter 18
Now that I have finished this one word: "Stunning".
imgonewiththewind 1/15/12 . chapter 18
I'm fighting back tears! This is so sad.. It's very well-written.
HelenSES 1/11/12 . chapter 3
Wow! What a great story. I am loving this. I like the fact that you have made Scarlett a strong lady and I like this side of Rhett too!
lsargoy 4/24/11 . chapter 1
This is a wonderful interpretation of what happen to Scarlett and Rhett. I really think this is close to what Margaret Mitchell intended and the integration of the Impressionist movement is very clever! Extremely well done!
CeKhay 12/15/10 . chapter 18
I loved this. Absolutely positively adore this. I'm glad I found this and was able to read it. Because I loved it.

CeKay
AliceInWonDerLandAlwaYs 10/8/10 . chapter 18
omg I can't stop crying, that was so incredibly beautifully written, specially the last part of Rhett's letter. I blame you entirely for making me sit up all night (it is now almost 4 am) and being all sentimental :P
Multiple Sarcasms 8/31/10 . chapter 18
i cried my freaking heart out. you see, i thought that i had run out of tears in the chapters before. i was mistaken. my vision is blurring. you are that fantastic!

i acknowledge this as the rightful conclusion to their tale, and my god...

and as much as it pains me, i have to agree with your opinion here, they could not have reconciled sooner, they were not happy people /3

take care, and i love you.
xsofax 8/20/10 . chapter 18
I just finished reading this entire story,

I thought it was beautiful. Both characters are well written, I also thought it very convincing that rhett could be so bitter sometimes. I think, for some reason I always expected him to be like this when he got older.

btw, this 'sequel' to GWTW was probably more accurate in how the story would go after the ending of the book than Alexandra Ripley's version.

E.g. Rhett getting a misstress in stead of a wife is so much more realistic.

It was also nice to experience everyone grown up, especially Scarlett, to see how she is with her grandchildren.

Haha, I don't think I've ever written a review this long :'P

Sophie
mshappygolucky 8/10/10 . chapter 18
This story is absolutely lovely...I still have tears in my eyes from that very poignant ending. The interactions Scarlett has with her children and grandchildren are so well done and the slowly coming love and peace that come to Scarlett and Rhett is right on. I loved reading how tender she was with him, kissing his forehead and holding his hand. Thank you for sharing this. I have always hoped that these two would find their way back together and, even though their time together is short, I can see this coming from their stubborness and pain. So wonderful!
EugeniaVictoria 6/9/10 . chapter 18
I did weep! this was so very beautiful. "You were my one true love." that really made me cry. amazing job.
Vee22 6/1/10 . chapter 18
Oh! To call this story a tearjerker is truly an understatement. I finished reading it almost 10 minutes ago and the tears are still cascading down my cheeks!

How can a review of mine possibly do this justice? All I can say is that it was unique, beautiful, poetic, heart-wrenching. and oh, so wonderfully written. And it's also going on my Favorites list.

*Reaches for an extra supply of tissues.*
Crogos 4/27/10 . chapter 18
I finally worked up the courage to read this fic. It lived up to every expectation and positively ripped my heart out. So beautifully written, I don't even know what to say. That last scene, when Scarlett has a flashback, just killed me. So heart-breakingly beautiful. I have no words.
isolabella 4/1/10 . chapter 18
It took me several months to summon up the fortitude to read this story, for I knew it would be devastatingly sad. But I am so thankful that I did read it at long last. Words cannot fully explain how deeply this story moved me. It is a staggering accomplishment. A masterpiece. Thank you.
214 found: Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. 15 Next »
Return to Top