Aww Poor Charlie! He is such a great character and I love his and Bellas relastionship.

This was a great insight to what he was feeling when Edward left Bella, and so well writtien! :)

Wow, I never saw a Charlie P.O.V. coming from you :P
It's really good and unique. I love it!
But...just have to, can't stop myself; are updates to pre-existing stories in the future :P I've been waiting a long time you know. You promised :P!

Hearts :)

That was really good!! its exactly like i thought it would be like (if i had thought of it...) but the ending was really good too!!

Excellent insight to Charlie. I love it. Poor guy.

that was good you shoudl contion it that would be awsoem so later gator