 Marlowe97 2009-10-02 . chapter 18This is amazing! I started with this, not really knowing where it would head - it was a little long for just "oh, the CPS comes visiting - crap, we need to move, fight, fight, yelling - comfort" like it usually is.
But this - I don't know, somewhere in between it changed.
The idea with the paper was cool, it could have ended in any way like a lot of those do - Sam realizing his awesome brother, blahblahblah... but no, you made it work. And I'm sorry, but I can't tell you why exactly.
I LOVE the way you painted the family-dynamics, with everything as we know it - Dean doing everything for his family, Sam being smart, John being absent - but that everyone has to be careful around Dean when he is cranky, cause they don't want to face his temper - that is such a brilliant idea! It's such a little thing, really, but it gives a great dynamic to the piece. I like your John - for exactly the reasons Sam is so surprised: he sees Deans pain and misery, knows it even through a phone - and still miss his 21st birthday, doesn't know where he works and stuff like that.
I also like the principal and his pal. Amazing how they turned out to be more than just the usual over concerned (though I think there should be NO over concern for possible abuse) social-workers with no clue.
Nope, you made them likeable, even though you took your time and I had to go through a little annoyance about them first ;-)
I had a lot of fun with the brother-banter in the office: "Sam, do we eat?" "Every Thursday" - LOL
The jocks were pretty funny, such idjits.
Aw, Dean reading that paper over and over - sweet! But Sammy - seriously? I don't really know, maybe your family handled things differently, but in MY family, we call the one who has a birthday - and don't wait for him/her to call US. But for such a bright kid, he could be a little slow, once in a while...
All in all, this was a pleasure to read! I'll put it on my favorite-list right away - I don't want it to slip away...
And wow, the idea with the legal guardian - just cool. Really interesting concept, should have been done in 'real'(aka:TV) life too, cause that would have taken a lot of problems out of the way. Maybe you should suggest that to the writers *winknudge* |
 maipigen 2009-05-05 . chapter 20Now this story I liked even better than the other one - mainly because this time ALL the winchesters seemed in character!
I lvoed John here, he's an A.hole some time but his heart is in the right place.
The custody thing I haven't read before so that was good too.
I love stories where Sam is in High School and even better one where Dean is too.
Please consider writing a new one with both Winchester children in shcool - it's my favorite and my birthday is coming up lol. I can't write it myself, I'm not a good enough writer, sigh...
Anyhoo, loved this story and will also favorite this one.
Please write rapidly more!
Happy future writing
Ditte Mai |