|Reviews for The Treasure of Captain Cannonsmoke|
| Maximara 11/22/12 . chapter 2
It is real hard for a real Tracy fan to get into this story and the reason is in addition to using Tracy as a framing device for their own set of lame characters the UPA cartoon played fast and loose with Tracy's Rogue Gallery.
In 1960 Flattop, BB Eyes, Itcy, Oodles, Mumbles, Pruneface and Brow had been long killed off in the comic strip. While loopholes in three (BB Eyes, Mumbles, and Pruneface) would be used to bring them back the others were killed of in such ways (The Brow was impaled on a flagpole in 1944 for example) that they could only be brought back in flashback or via previously unknown relations.
| TailsLovesCosmo 9/14/11 . chapter 27
Nice story up to this point, but it's disappointing seeing the characters from the show where Tracy never did anything but talk into his two way wrist radio. Would have preferred seeing Tracy's actual team, including Sam Catchem and Junior, or even B. O. Plenty, Vitamin Flintheart, and Moon Maid.
| TailsLovesCosmo 9/11/11 . chapter 5
Stooge Viller was probably based on Edward G. Robinson. He was the one that killed Junior's father. When is this taking place?
| TailsLovesCosmo 9/11/11 . chapter 4
Where is Tracy all this time? These guys are experienced crooks and should realize no one would invite all ten of them onboard his ship unless he had plans to deal with them if they got out of hand.
| TailsLovesCosmo 9/11/11 . chapter 2
Interesting idea but real gold would bend just like lead.
| princessebee 1/3/11 . chapter 30
I enjoyed this story very much. It was fun and though very playful and even a bit silly (obviously on purpose), still made the bad guys feel like bad guys.
I think generally was just an overcrowding of characters. You write them all very well, but none of them had enough time. I'm glad you saw the story all the way through with a full plot and denoument.
Big complaint: not anywhere near enough Flattop. In fact, if you were to ever write a DT story again, I'd love a whole story just on Flattop. If you gave it a romantic plot/subplot, I would die of happiness. I cannot find ANY Flattop fanfic!
| lostangel007 9/25/10 . chapter 1
WOW. Thank you so much for writing this and taking your time to upload this. I was a kid when "Dick Tracy" hit the theatres in 1990, and I was obsessed with the movie/the cartoon/comic. I use to always come up with stories about Mumbles and Stooge. You have captured all of the cartoon characters perfectly, and I could really hear Stooge's voice in my head when I was reading his lines. Thank you so much for this. I am just curious, and I hope you don't mind me asking, how old are you? I was 11 when I was watching the cartoon on channel 38, the summer that the movie came out. :)
Keep up the good work please!
| EmmetEarwax 7/5/09 . chapter 2
Of course,one VERY interesting Tracy villain was the SHAPE-CHANGING PuttyPuss -who could look like ANYBODY he wished ! He's still around because the artistwriter team found him a LOT of fun !
| Paul R Wilson 7/5/09 . chapter 2
This labor of love is like the old Dick Tracy cartoon show (in ONE respect: the show was silly !). The criminals are from many diff. points of time in the Dick Tracy series, and most were KILLED in the stories, only a few living to become reformed, useful members of society. BUT here they are together !
I recall also the elaborate death traps set for Tracy -one ALMOST worked and that's because it was realistic: a sniper !
| Jen Rock 6/7/09 . chapter 30
I'm sorry to see this end as it reminded me of why I'm a fan of Dick Tracy. It was just such a fun story and you did a great job in juggling all the characters and keeping them in character. I did kind of hope that Mumbles and Stooge would escape but I knew it wasn't likely. The criminal's "soccer" match was perfect and it was even more amusing that Heap narrated it instead of breaking it up. Great job.
| Jen Rock 4/19/09 . chapter 23
This just gets better and better as it goes along. It was very clever of Stooge to grab the map and now the Brow's in trouble. I'm looking forward to seeing how this all gets resolved. Hopefully, it will involve going back and getting Stooge and Mumbles again.
| Jen Rock 3/28/09 . chapter 20
I think Sketch is going to be in trouble now if the others think he's hypnotizing them into killing each other. And Mumbles can blame his trying to blow up the ship on him as well which will get him off the hook. It seems like they're all going to be at each others throats too much to ever reach the treasure but perhaps that's what the mysterious Captain Cannonsmoke wants. I look forward to more.
| Jen Rock 2/7/09 . chapter 13
This is very well-done and Dick Tracy fics are certainly a rarity. I love the way the villains are trying to work together but are being tripped up by their own evil natures into being at each others throats. Mumbles is my favorite so I hope he doesn't end up dead although I doubt he's going to enjoy the beating they'll give him if he survives. I look forward to more.
| Dick Tracy 1/23/09 . chapter 1
YES! I love dick tracy! Thank you for writing one!