 angry penguin 2009-06-23 . chapter 1Damn him. :( |
 Dr. Who Nut 2008-12-07 . chapter 1Do you think he would really do that? I can almost see him doing that, but I'm not sure he would be able to live with himself. then again, he might...
good job, it makes me think. |
 Mira-Jade 2008-11-23 . chapter 1Oh lands, I am actually crying at the end of this. That was beautiful, power, poignant and a thousand other adjectives like that. Wow!
I am not a Doctor/Donna fan, but this was too beautiful for me to pass up leaving a thought. I like how much you say with so few words - really, a job well done with this. |
 Willow08 2008-11-23 . chapter 1I really love this - beautiful writing and fantastic idea
completely heartbreaking but brilliant all the same |
 Laura Harkness 2008-11-23 . chapter 1despite myself, because i'm not a huge fan of these kinds of things, i have to say that i liked this A LOT.
what he did to her has always kind of creeped me out. he is, in fact, and always has been kind of creepy. i suppose you can justify it by saying he almost has to be because he lives so long.. is so OLD both in spirit and mind.
still... what he did to donna (and in fact what he did to rose at the end as well) is in some ways unjustifiable...
it is a theme i seem to keep revisiting in my long, rambling space opera... for example, chapter 5 of 'abomination' where i write about the "terrible deed." BUT (and here we come back to you, finally!!) you do it better and with far more poignancy and (to your credit!) brevity.
so while i might disagree with you on his motivation (love, i don't know.. shame, most definately yes), i have to say:
nice work! |
 ChellusAuglerie 2008-11-22 . chapter 1Oh...man. Taht ** in the red dress is SO the RANI. Whaddya you think? |
 xXDonnaTylerXx 2008-11-22 . chapter 1Need I leave a review? Even if I did, is not possible due to deadness of moi. Just... beautiful. Seriously, I'm crying like emo!nine would at the sight of sexy!ten and rose gettijg married. poor little big eared weirdo... bless.
Must... write... a... ten... /... donna...
D x |
 HowBrightWeShine 2008-11-22 . chapter 1Right. I have a NUMBER of things to say about this! >:(
**CON-CRIT STUFF (NOT BAD)**
1) "…and legs were shaking with the effort of standing up." Did you mean "...and HER legs ARE shaking with the effort of standing up? :S
2) "She was going to die." You MIGHT have meant "She IS going to die", if it's present tense.
3)"…irrelivantly…" Not a word, accoring to our dear old mother. *huggles Mum* Right. You could have said something like "A totally irrelevant thought crosses his mind: She's beautiful". Something like that...8D
**ACTUAL REVIEW**
JAG HATAR DIG MYCKET! (I HATE YOU MUCH!)
Heartbreaking! Angsty! Adorable! Sad! Doctor/Donna-y! Brilliant! Fantastic! Molto bene! All of the above words describe this oneshot! JAG HATA DU FÖR VARELSE SÅDEN EN GOD FÖRFATTAREN! (I HATE YOU FOR BEING SUCH A GOOD WRITER!, found out via an English-Swedish online translation thing. :D)
IT'S A GREAT (badword) STORY! BE (badword) PROUD! While I sulk in a corner over lack of talent. *gives thumbs-up and 10 out of 10 stars, before retreating to dark corner and being moody* |
|