Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: It's a Wonderful Life
you know who
2009-05-18 . chapter 1
brilliant padfoot. as always. yes, i did re-read it but i love it anyway...
Is pizza calling your name?
OMG Remember bacon and eggs and sausage?
Well, we had a pizza too.
Farewell.
the one, the only,
Masper
Eleve Osirian
2009-01-12 . chapter 1
I decided I'd review for you. Note that I haven't read the books (blasphemy I know) so my review will focus on sentences and what I can derive from what you've presented. I enjoyed reading this piece, and hope my suggestions will help.

Suggestions:
Could be having a complete dumb moment here but did you mean to say, "every evening till gone midnight"?

"at least nobody ever asked any questions"-you could cut this sentence down and avoid the uneeded words. An example might be, "At least nobody asked questions." You do need the ever and any because it just weighs the sentence down and makes it a bit sluggish. Check your other sentences for little things like this.

The first sentence you say, "the two of them." In the following paragraph, the first sentence also contains the same thing. "there were two of them." We know there are two, so you don't need to repeat this. (you could, but I would word it differently if you keep it)

Careful of repetitive words like flat, then, etc. Try using a different word to describe the place your characters are living. For nitpicky readers, it gets old.

And some advice a beta reader gave me. "Try to avoid the as, then, and which's"-they make your writing seem more amaturish and elementary than it is. It's something I too, need to work on, but I thought I would pass it along to you. =)
Maths Is Immortal
2008-12-09 . chapter 1
Ah, that was really good! Well done!

Thought he might have been testing them with the pizza, but I didn't see the end coming until it was practically happening! :o Shocking and brilliant story!
Eleanor Rigby
2008-12-04 . chapter 1
i meant names
THis is Eleanor Rigby
2008-12-04 . chapter 1
Padfoot. YOU ARE INSANE!!
but good. we must never forget the good.
i have five minutes so i must write fast.
what's the elvish at the top of your profile say?
tel me at forum.
this was wicked good. yet crazy. i guess some things are both...
so good job. u never cease to amaze me.
bye!!
me
one more thing...
Valentine? out of all the manes in the world...
Return to Top