Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: The Elf in the Easel
PriestMahado7 2/8/10 . chapter 1
OH MY GOD! That was so good! I never really thought about it before, but Karim's totally the Celtic Guardian! And it really makes sense that Pegasus would be the reincarnation of Akunadin... Now I feel really stupid for not realizing that before... But this was really, great, just like the Mahad one! You should continue it!
LostOzian 12/7/08 . chapter 1
Why has nobody reviewed this? This is good. There's a lot if discrepency about who Shada and Karim were reincarnated as, the most common guesses being Shadi and Odion/Rishid, but I do like your interpretation of Karim as Celtic Guardian. It certainly makes sense, with so many of Yami's protectors surrounding him in his new life.

I also like how you portray Pegasus, because he really does do the wrong things for the right reasons. It's why he's a temporary bad guy. It might have been nice if Mahad had been recognized if he saw all the others, or maybe even if Mahad was only half-completed. That would have been interesting. Especially if you continue. Celtic Guardian gets killed a lot, so his perspective on duels would be interesting. Or maybe if he watched Pegasus in his daily life. There are more similarities between Ahknadin and Pegasus than we usually realize; feel free to explore that. -LostOzian
Return to Top