Yes, it did sound like it was from 'When the Stars Smile'! I liked all their points of view, especially Caranthir's (and that's not just because he's the definition of awesomeness!) I like this collection of Feanorion randomness - it's quite amusing.

~Araloth

This is a nice piece of character work. I like these varying views on Finrod; the contrast between what the various C-relatives think of him is well done. Thanks!

I really like this fic, it's very funny and I hope you continue, however, in keeping with my penname, I have to point out that chapter 6 is titled 'the 3 c's', when in fact there are four in the story. Just thought I'd point that out LOL. Keep writing

Yay, Finrod! Serves the sons of Feanor right! These are interesting perspectives each offers on Finrod and the insight it offers into each one's persona and character flaws. I like Celebrimbor's the best.

teehee they do have quite a bit to complain about!

How very true! I do like the possible daughters and the difficulties of making up their merely potential minds. Thanks!

Poor Celebrimbor! Everyone is in a difficult position here, except perhaps for the single-minded sons of Feanor. Thanks!

I had not considered Celebrimbor's view point on this before or his role or lack thereof in the fight against the third kinslaying. Well thought out and nicely done!

I like this take on the meeting of the adopted twins. Very realistic. I also liked the guards at the end seeming to hope that they wouldn't get stuck with the kids.

nicely done!

A nice bit of fun! The idea of Ereinion Gil-galad, Scion of Kings, hitting his uncle over the head with a toy soldier, had me snickering not unlike like his father!

"We Feanorions are not easily separated from our toys." Very nice! gives point to the humour beautifully. Thanks!