Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Scarlet
Astalavisbay
2008-12-19 . chapter 1
*gasp*. Yes, I've read that version and wasn't is the sweetest when Charles choose Erik over Raoul? Anyway, very very nice. Sweet even. I love the whole understanding thing and the Erik/Christine. Tis a realistic yet romantic story.
AlexGhost
2008-12-18 . chapter 1
That was very well written, good job. :3
Dancingpuppy1014
2008-12-18 . chapter 1
I dont know what to write...
I have read Kay's novel and this piece seems like it could be a missing scence with a few tweeking here and there but otherwise in general its exellent...if to be grades it would be a 90's.

Can I just ask I heared many about white rose and nightingale and the forbidden red rose but what is the exact story behind it?

I mean i get it but i am just curious to know where it came from and stuff
Isabella101
2008-12-18 . chapter 1
Thank you so much for posting this.
It truly is beautifully written :)

-Isabella-
_Natku_
2008-12-18 . chapter 1
Mira! You have seriously made my day!

It's wonderful to see you return to your Phantom roots. This was an interesting topic, and beautifully done. As always. Damn, but do you know how to tug at a gal's heartstrings. Strangely enough, Raould's segment was my favorite. I almost feel bad for him . . . almost.

Thanks a bil' for this amazing lil' gem!
Return to Top