|Reviews for Gone|
| HiddenHeartHiddenIdentity 8/26/12 . chapter 1
I actually feel a little bit sorry for Isobel here! Thank you for writing this amazing one-shot! It's a shame it's the only one, but maybe - hopefully - someone will write more :) xxx
| colourfulchatterbox 1/19/12 . chapter 1
I really don't want to feel sorry for Isobel...but I kinda do...:P
Fantastic, you have captured Eva Ibbotson's style PERFECTLY.
Thank you for sharing this with us :)
| i'llbringhimdown 10/23/11 . chapter 1
beautiful story, perfectly written!
| LucyCrewe11 8/23/11 . chapter 1
Well written little piece, and very in-canon with the book. In character as well. But even while this was told from her point of view, it doesn't make me feel for Isobel any more than the actual book did; I still think she got exactly what she deserved. She was greedy and weak. Because this was a fanfiction told from her point of view, something that could have made a reader symathize with her a little more potentically, I think you should have done in this in the first-person because otherwise, it's too much like what we already know of Isobel via Eva Ibbtson's words. That aside, your writting style was very good.
| nut-tree 7/16/11 . chapter 1
(this is my first review on fanfiction so feel extra honoured XD )
a really great adition to my (joint) favourate book! you have a beautiful , flowing style of writeing that compliments Ibbotsons and i read the whole thing almost without realiseing - which is the mark of wonderful writeing. well done! and thank you for writeing it!
| StoryBug13 5/23/11 . chapter 1
Wow! I haven't read any fanfics on A Company of Swans, before this one... they're practically an endangered species! I think you wrote this in true Ibbotson style, and the story pulled me in just like hers do! Well done! I loved it.
| Marshmallows rock 10/31/09 . chapter 1
I never thought I would see a fanfiction for this book - I think it should be made required reading. Do you have a favourite character? Simonova is mine :)
Regarding the story, I really enjoyed it, very emotive and reflective. It's something I often wonder while reading the book myself.
| SingingBird812 9/11/09 . chapter 1
It's interesting to see something from Isobel's point of view! A Company of Swans is one of my favorite books, so it was pretty exciting to find this story. :)
| daysandweeks 2/18/09 . chapter 1
Ah! I'm in love with Eva Ibbotson's books, and I'm so glad I found this. There is not enough fanfic out there...this is the only one I've seen, in fact. Brilliant job!