that was such a good but sad chapter. wondering if Carlisle is gonna leave Bella? well it was very well written and i hope, i cant wait to read the next chapter. love the story!

:-)

-Isabella.C.-

Great Chapter! Bella should really talk to Carlisle instead of shutting him out...

Great chapter. Poor bella now she's going to be thorn betwenn going back with Edward and him finding out, or staying with Carlisle and him leaving sad sad sad

Great chapter! Clever Jake, but I hope Bella and Carlisle have a talk about their relationship?

Please update!

aw...so not cool Jake!

I'd take Carlisle over Jacob and Edward ANY day. Haha. Please update soon! :]

Haha. "I knew it" That was great. Post soon.

Jake prefers Carlisle over Edward...Lol! I loved the past few chapters and I am glad that Carlisle comes to check on her. Otherwise it would be a long couple years! Haha, I am also glad that Jake is agreeable when it comes to her and Carlisle. Great chapter and update soon!

lol well THAT was interesting so jakey is happier with carlisle then with edward?

It's a relief that Jacob's going to keep it a secret... oh well. Amazing chapter and I loved it a lot. I just really love your story! Update soon!

love it!

A few ulterior motives Jake? I think so! :) LOL, although he must really hate Edward if he's just glad that Bella's moved on to another "bloodsucker."

Nice chapter! Update very soon! I hope Bella and Carlisle run off together in the near future. ;)

This story is so addictive. I just thought that Jacob would b more pissed then that. Can't wait till Edward finds out! Keep up the good work!

awesome! keep it coming please!