|Reviews for If You Could Ask|
| FemaleSpock 10/24/11 . chapter 1
Nice fic! I really enjoyed reading it.
| blue morning tide 9/24/10 . chapter 1
So it's been a while since you originally wrote this fic, but I was just rereading HtS and realized that I really wanted to find some Johnny/Gareth background story. I knew the odds weren't good, since there are so few Sevenwaters stories out there, but lo and behold! Thanks so much for writing this, it was exactly what I was looking for and quite well-written to boot. My only qualm is that everyone was just a bit too accepting—I imagine, given the time period, that that wouldn't really be the case. Still, it was a good read. And if you've still got those oneshots floating around, I am definitely interested!
| Ailin5 6/4/10 . chapter 1
A wonderful story painting a wonderful picture of Johnny and Gareth. I always wanted to know more about their story, so this was perfect :) Thank you!
| too-much-like-Luna 4/5/10 . chapter 1
So, I really wanted to give you a awesome and eloquent review, but that's not going to happen because I have a really bad head cold. But I'll atempt it.
I really loved the Johnny/Gareth aspect in Heir to Sevenwaters, and if J. Marillier has decided not to give us more back story, this is totally what I would want for it. It's sweet and a little angsty, and the characters are well developed and very in character.
I was wondering if, perhaps, you'd consider letting me record this and make a podfic out of it? My livejournal can be found at dreaming-athena. is you'd like to hear my voice before deciding. Alternately, I could record the fic (or a part of it) and send it to you if you give me an email address, if you'd like to hear what it would sound like. Thank you for considering it.
| TheBooknerd 2/25/10 . chapter 1
Wonderfully written! This series is filled with great characters, and you do a great job of portraying them. I didn't expect to actually find any Sevenwaters fics went I went looking for them, so I was thrilled to see a Johnny/Gareth story. I loved what you did with this relationship, especially the non-proposal. Very sweet.
| Friendly Legolas Sporker 1/29/10 . chapter 1
Cute. I usually don't read slash, but this was really good and I need more JM in my life.
| kittennic 1/1/10 . chapter 1
Beautiful story - well written :)
| siriuspuppy 9/1/09 . chapter 1
I love this story!So sweet and very well written. Thank you!
| Viorica 5/7/09 . chapter 1
That was absolutely lovely. I was thrilled to see a gay couple in one of Juliet's books, and the fact that there's this sweet fic for them (with Cathal providing comic relief) . . . like I said, lovely.
| The Balrog of Altena 1/13/09 . chapter 1
I'm so happy to have found this fic! Juliet Marillier needs more fanfiction! I wish I could read one good Faolan/Bridei story (no need for slash, I love friendship stories) but for now I'm content with this one )
I was surprised to see Juliet make a gay pair, I would have never thought that of her... she so into the romantic "needy man" and the "valiant woman"
| secret-scribbled-notebooks 1/8/09 . chapter 1
Am very interested in oneshot series. JM needs more fics:)
I thought this needed more explanation in the book. how cool is the open-endedness of it all?
great job:)hope you continue with more like this!