Wow...very dark , but well-written all the same. Great job! It's hard to believe that Minerva would be evil like that, but when you turn the idea over in your head, it makes sense in a very disturbing, other-universe-kind of way. Well-done!

...what the f$@#

Wow, I don't think I've ever read an evil Minerva story before. she's definitely quite scary ! Interesting retelling of Puss in Boots.

Oh... I hate the thought that my favorite character (Professor McGonagall) could possibly be evil, but this was well-written enough that I was doubting her a bit afterward, well done!! I really like the "fairy tale" element to this fic; having read Beedle the Bard it's hard not to want more of those kinds of stories, and this fits the bill perfectly. Excellent writing!

I shivered and thought of the Tales of Beedle the Bard the whole time. Well done, I really enjoyed it.