Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Glorfindel of Gondolin
Agena K.
2009-11-08 . chapter 1
I'm in quarantine for at least a week and needed a good story to send me to bed this not only fit the bill but made me cry for the happiness of Glorifindel's begetting day and the finding of his journal.

Such a wonderful gift that Dan and Ro gave him. Wow

Such a wonderful gift that you gave me.

than's so much! * (10 stars)I'd give you all that you deserve but I'd run out of characters!
Jude
SecretlyInInk
2009-07-02 . chapter 1
This story was quite touching.
Very good job.
La-p'tite-tete
2009-03-10 . chapter 1
Oh, that was so cute! ^^ I especially liked the last words. A really nice fic!
Ducky'sgirl4ever
2009-02-15 . chapter 1
A great story. Very good.
Windsurfbabe
2009-02-13 . chapter 1
Very, very sweet. I enjoyed this one-shot a lot, since Glorfindel and the twins are my favourite characters, and I thank you for it.
PurpleHat
2009-02-12 . chapter 1
Beautiful and poignant.

The interaction between the twins is spot on. Erestor, in his brief appearance, is believably stern on the outside, but soft-hearted underneath. Glorfindel's pleasure in the thoughtful gift, with all its associated memories is very moving.

Once again you manage to pack a lot of characterisation and plot into a one-shot - a vehicle which all too often lacks either.
Elfinabottle
2009-02-11 . chapter 1
You have such a gift for describing a scene. You mnade that dusty library come to life. I laughed out loud at Elrohir dropping a spider on his brother's head.

And what a thoughtful gift. I imagine Glorfindel is usually kind of hard to buy for. :-)
Wraithlike
2009-02-11 . chapter 1
Aw, that is just adorable. I loved the twin thing at the beginning.

"Erestor thinks you should have stopped me."

Hilarious. But it was very sweet, especially at the end. I love Glorfindel. A really lovely idea, very well executed.

GO YOU!!
moonshine4488
2009-02-11 . chapter 1
Aw...very sweet. I just love Glorfindel and twin moments :)
CAH
2009-02-11 . chapter 1
What a sweet thing for them to do. And isn't it true that one usually picks up what's nearest and not what's most important? Thank goodness she picked that up-at least Glorfindel has one tie to his Gondolin left.

It's a wonderful little story Jay! And a great way to begin a morning!

Will we ever know just what the terrible two did to bring the wrath of Erestor down upon them?
Lady Ambreanna
2009-02-10 . chapter 1
Very sweet! Thank you so much for the story! ;)
JastaElf
2009-02-10 . chapter 1
THAT is positively wonderful! What a great, sweet tale--and SO likely to have happened! And this is just the most wonderful pair of sentences:

"people snatched up whatever was nearest to hand when we fled, not necessarily the most vital things. And somehow – despite everything – it came here.”

So true... so likely... and just wonderful, as are all the things you write. Thank you so much for sharing this with us!!
Slayer3
2009-02-10 . chapter 1
I love it! Although techincally Glorifindel of Gondolin and Glorifindel of Rivendell are two different people,as far as the books go anyway. Atlhough...hm It would very interesting if they were the same person er elf lol...Anywho I love it..very very nice...Its an interesting debate, like the whole do balrogs have wings or not? LOL



Slayer,the completly obsessed fangirl
IMSGSET and Sue Squad member
Clodia
2009-02-10 . chapter 1
This is rather charming. Nice idea. Thank you!
Return to Top