Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Winds
L' Ame Force 12/26/11 . chapter 1
Amun and Benjamin are apparently from ancient Egypt. That being said...

I give you an immense amount of points for seeking to provide historical accuracy into a meyerpire's past. This is something that SM irritatingly (and insultingly) does not do. See exhibit A: Carlisle Cullen. See exhibit B: Rosalie Hale. See exhibit C: Esme Cullen. See exhibit D: Jasper Hale.

As for the side characters like Benjamin, I could go on.
So kudos to you! Side characters fascinate me, especially when they're essentially blank slates.
CatchEmAllEe 11/13/10 . chapter 1
That was good I can totally see that being what happened I like how you did his voice, very confident and funny)
Leah M. W 3/30/10 . chapter 1
Very good, and very accurate
persephonesfolly 11/13/09 . chapter 1
Sorry to hear you've quit fanfiction. Especially after reading this really creative perspective on Benjamin. There just wasn't enough of him in the Twilight series!

Sure, Amon may have been a tad OOC (can't really see Mr. Miffed and Dignified from BD cosying up to the British) but Benjamin's description of him as 'creepy man/monster' was a hoot.
The Last Letter 5/25/09 . chapter 1
You should write more, about his waking up, what happened to the others in his gang (just cause I'd really like to know about that), meeting Tia, all of that. You're a good writer.

DI4MGZ
Bailey 3/18/09 . chapter 1
u need to write more so the fans can read this book is good!
CaptainSkitzoVamp 3/8/09 . chapter 1
once again you pulled it off really well by only doing research

i would love to read a story about when benjamin "woke up"you could say.

either way i liked it:)
AB 2/17/09 . chapter 1
Ah, I reviewed twice D: oh well. don't pretend you don't love it XD
xAndromedaBlackx 2/16/09 . chapter 1
Benjamin is so cute I love him. great job XD
the fallen dead 2/15/09 . chapter 1
Wow, you've made Benjamin into an amazing character. He seems unintentionally funny. I love it, great job. Good way to describe the change.
xAndromedaBlackx 2/13/09 . chapter 1
I'm too lazy to log in, haha :D but this was awesome! Just... awesome. Yeah. Benjamin was so cute, whether or not he wants to admit it ;D
ElianaMargalit 2/12/09 . chapter 1
Unfortunately, I've never learned about this time period either. It's really too bad, it sounds interesting. (Way more interesting than learning about The French and Indian War like I am right now. :P) So I don't if you made any mistakes with the history.

But this was great. Much better than my attempt to write about Benjamin...(I took it off FFnet because it was really bad and didn't have any reviews. :P) Great job. :D
Return to Top