Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Flawed - Page 1 of 2
stephanie du jour
2009-08-16 . chapter 4
A wonderful end to the quartet!
stephanie du jour
2009-08-16 . chapter 3
This chapter was awesomely awesome.
stephanie du jour
2009-08-16 . chapter 2
Beautiful. This chapter made me cry.
stephanie du jour
2009-08-16 . chapter 1
I'm swept away in this story, short as it is. The choice of present tense really works.
BittersweetSummer
2009-07-09 . chapter 4
Ohh, what a powerful story. I enjoyed reading every single one of them. I had to say that I liked Lucy and Edmund's the best.

These are such well-written stories, and I have no words to describe how much I adore them!

Brilliantly done.

:D
Shizuku Tsukishima749
2009-07-01 . chapter 4
AW! The ending was so sad! I definitely recognized the 'Susan knew Aslan' part from the section of LB where she asks Edmund is he knows Aslan and he says, "No, but He knows me." ^_^

Gosh...Lucy's was so sad when it concerned Susan! Edmund's was really creepy because it concerned the White Witch! Peter's was sad, too, as he thought about his times in Narnia and the train! Susan's...gosh, Susan's was so depressingly uplifting as she believed, denied, and missed her siblings all in one! T.T

Rock on! This was absolutely amazing!! ^U^ *U*
Ever-so sincerely signed,
Shizuku Tsukishima749 :D ;D :) ;)
Alisara
2009-06-29 . chapter 4
Love all your quartets. You deal with the faith, and the topic of Susan insightfully. Always a pleasure to read your work.
Highqueen Julietta
2009-05-25 . chapter 1
wow,I loved it! cant wait to read the next chapter *click*
Miniver
2009-05-23 . chapter 3
For my money, this is the best chapter of all. The splendid description of Edmund's relationship to Peter at the beginning, with Peter supplying the objective and Edmund the method, set the scene right away, and things only got better after that. Edmund's temptation is exactly what he would fall for at this point in his life: the suggestion that the ends would justify the means because his disobedience of Aslan would be for the high purpose of protecting Narnia. Even though I know what the outcome of the recovery of the rings should be, my heart was in my mouth about how Edmund would resolve things. You really topped yourself with this one.
Miniver
2009-05-23 . chapter 2
I'm thrilled to see more of this story. I certainly don't envy the challenge you set yourself with Lucy! You structured this chapter wonderfully, and you made her wish for completeness in this world completely believable. The description of her encounter with Aslan at the end fits her loving personality perfectly.
rthstewart
2009-05-23 . chapter 3
As you say, there are many ways to take Edmund and this is a very good one here. Peter supplying the objective, Edmund the means. So very true. I enjoyed this take on Edmund as someone who continues to struggle with temptation. He is not perfect, still has that darkness, and we admire him for always and continuing to resist it.
rthstewart
2009-05-23 . chapter 1
This is a wonderful glimpse into Peter. First, of course, is his protectiveness. His last thoughts are of how to protect others, and then his acceptance, last image and first are of Aslan. His strength comes in his acceptance and recognition of his flaws, which is, of course part of the purpose of these vignettes. A lovely character piece. I also really enjoyed the comment that faith and belief are two things that he has never had a lot of, and of course he finds both at the end.
GuitarGirl496
2009-05-23 . chapter 3
I like this chapter. I could feel how Edmund was feeling, the temptation and how hard it was to just let it go. Great job!
PwnedByPineapple
2009-03-16 . chapter 2
Wow... this is absolutely amazing. Very well-written and beautiful. Wonderful job:)
The Owl's Pen
2009-03-16 . chapter 2
More please! I want my Edmund!
Return to Top