Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: The Best Gift - Page 1 of 2
everyme
2009-09-11 . chapter 1
Hey :D
Quite a nice one-shot, I have to say. There aren´t many Severus Snape/Minerva McGonagall stories out there, the pairing doesn´t seem to be very popular with fans. Rather disappointing, I think, because the books don´t really mention many major confrontations between them, so I think fanfiction authors have free reign to explore them.
Yours was very nicely written, and I really liked the plot. Somehow,it´s the simple things that count, like feeling comfortable again after being out in a snowstorm.
Minerva was very in character; though she didn´t show it, you could really tell that she cares for Severus. Another thing I liked about you depiction of her is that she wan´t as much of a mother hen as Poppy; Severus would really be fed up with another one like Poppy, I think.
Snape mentioning that this was propably the best birthday present he ever reveived was just the perfect ending :D

Hope you continue writing such interesting stories :D
greets
Fayet
2009-08-11 . chapter 1
..I can indeed tell that you're in love with this characters. And I guess I really like them, too. At least in the way you picture them.
Santoryuu-Zoro
2009-07-28 . chapter 1
Yay! More Snapeness!! I was short and nice! It's nice how Minerva cares :)
Anachronistic Anglophile
2009-07-18 . chapter 1
Oh, that was so nice.
Valmarien
2009-05-06 . chapter 1
It's really sweet. Shame it can't happen like that in the books...
MaritimeStars
2009-04-30 . chapter 1
I love this story, so I reread and thought I should tell you how much I love it again. Great job, it was very well written and it put a smile on my face.
sevissick
2009-04-01 . chapter 1
Oh, how did I miss this story? My very favorite characters, written so beautifully, and one of my very favorite scenarios! It is so rare to find well-written stories in the H/C genre, so I treasure each one that I find. This one warms my heart.
Linoria
2009-03-14 . chapter 1
aw, so cute:D
Emmy
2009-03-04 . chapter 1
Aww, that was an adorable ending. Great fic, I loved it.
dragonpearlz
2009-03-03 . chapter 1
Very nice. :)

I think you should continue it - with Severus getting a bit worse, and Minerva taking care of him and defending him from Poppy. :-D
grugster
2009-03-03 . chapter 1
Lovely story! Thanks for writing it!
Healer Pomfrey
2009-02-28 . chapter 1
I loved it - they are my favourite characters too!
Chemistress
2009-02-28 . chapter 1
Yes, I could tell that you are in love with those characters - and as I am, too, I loved your little story and would like to read more of you.
Alcina vom Steinsberg
2009-02-28 . chapter 1
Ah, finally reviewing is possible again!
I love this little piece very much. This is such a perfect gift for anyone, and for Severus in particular. I love him being treated nicely and with friendship, consideration and care, and particularly by Minerva ;o) - and you did write it in such a lovely way...
MusicalAlchemy
2009-02-22 . chapter 1
Very sweet, i like how you've portrayed the staff in so few words :) A nice story, and a good read.

~MusicalAlchemy
Return to Top