 K'Ranna 10/30/03 . chapter 1Verra nice!
A little much on the drama there, but all in all a nice piece of writing. There were a few grammatical errors (barring the part where Dawn was scrabbling at his hands, as I figure that was for effect), and you made a mistake on the lyrics, but that's okay. ;
Oh, by the way - you have good taste in music. :D You're right, the lyrics probably don't fit the song, but the melody definitely does, and Tool's always said that the music means as much as the words do.
Have you ever seen the music video for Schism? If you haven't, it is so worth the millions of hours it'll take to download. *Lol* Really. Seriously. Tool videos are simply drool-worthy. Uh... a word of advice? DO NOT watch them for the first time right before bed. My friend had nightmares during a sleepover cuz I was showing her them. . |
 tia 4/28/03 . chapter 1 This was lovely angst ...
"I’ll be in hell wherever I am, because now wherever I am is not where you are, Summers. I’m dying without you in every way but the way that matters, love"
You captured Spike's pain and hopelessness and then his resolve to go on so wonderfully (and the lyrics really helped to evoke that mood too). I enjoyed this, Rashaka - thanks! |
 OlgaB 4/26/02 . chapter 1A great story... Really emotional. You brought out the best in the characters - thank you! |
 alex9 4/6/02 . chapter 1Well worh the review!
Very very good-like it a great deal.
alex |
 Trisha 12/30/01 . chapter 1Oooohhh wow! I really REALLY like this! You pack an AWFUL lot of emotion into every line, and it's just wonderful the way it works! I like the short sentences, I think it makes the strength of the character's emotions carry over better. And when Giles tells Spike that he doesn't deserve to know how Dawn is... Wow! Very powerful.
Great work! |
 heller 12/29/01 . chapter 1 Rashaka...I took your advice and downloaded the song and
listened to it while I read your story. The melody is so
haunting. I recommend listening to the song a couple of
times, reading the story, then the song.
About the story...poor Spike. This is one of the scenes
that I'd have loved to see on the show. Grief-striken
Spike...who utters absolutely the best line:
"I’ll be in hell wherever I am, because now wherever I am
is not where you are, Summers."
You write imagery very well...the coming dawn...Spike
grasping the dirt of the Buffy's grave. I also loved how
Giles was the one to bring him to his senses...and the
last line rocked!
Enjoyed it! |
 ashley 12/29/01 . chapter 1 It was a very emotional piece. Nice imagery. |
 Cypherwulf 12/29/01 . chapter 1 You write such great one-shots, I'd love to read a longer fic. Keep up the great work! |
 Trenesia 12/9/01 . chapter 1 Liked it. Hit the spot in the grief department. Thank you for writing. |
 n. bjelica 12/9/01 . chapter 1Perfect. Well-written and characterized. Nice work. :) |