| Reviews for Private Pomegranate |
|---|
draco-severus-mmm 1/25/12 . chapter 1Ah, Catch-22. A brilliant drabble about nothing, as Catch-22 was loath to do a lot of the time. You had your work cut out, but it could very well fit in to the rest of the story, too. |
Jankz 12/20/11 . chapter 1Wow, just, wow! You've really captured the esscence of Heller's witty and boggly writing technique; you have maintained his characters and made some excellent banter between them! Although the Catch-22 Fanfiction fandom is small, this story shines brightly! I hope (hope hope HOPE) that you'll pursue writing for this book sometime in the future (however, the chances of that appear dim). :/ Loved it! Jankz |
Formerly Chilltown 3/23/11 . chapter 1Nice, simple oneshot. Captured the spirit of Heller well, with the inverse statements, Dunbar seeking boredom, and such so. Successful fanfictional attempt. |
lovova 2/24/11 . chapter 1Awesome in its simplicity. Great job! |
Jewboy Extrordinaire 8/29/09 . chapter 1haha I'm really happy that people have written Catch 22 fanfics, cuz the book was such a revelation. good job |
minderbinder 6/17/09 . chapter 1You nailed the characters. I loved the imagery! |
The Joe and Gromit Show 6/14/09 . chapter 1Impressive. You've captured the frustratingly bewildering style of Catch-22 perfectly. Characterisation is excellent, and the characters themselves are all suitably nuts. Well done. :) For the only Catch-22 story thus far, you've set a good standard for others to follow. -Joe |
silverflight8 6/2/09 . chapter 1Sounds exactly like Catch-22...bewildering. You mimic the style very well. However, after a character says something, it's usually followed by a comma, apostraphe, and then a _lowercase_ letter. Not "Gimme a seed!" Yelled..., but instead "Gimme a seed!" yelled. Other than that, it was a good piece. Keep writing! |
tattooerofwalruses 4/24/09 . chapter 1Hey. Nicely done. Definetly(I never spell that word right) in Heller's style. I enjoyed this. Brief though it was |
Nongarak 4/20/09 . chapter 1Very nice. You have captured the spirit of Heller perfectly! |
HappyStickofTNT 4/14/09 . chapter 1That was a funny story. And I agree. It is better than the actual second book. We need more people to write fanfiction stories about Catch-22. *nods to self* yup. Sure do... |
bjkatcher 3/31/09 . chapter 1It's better than the real life sequal, that's for sure. |