Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Why James? - Page 1 of 2
Ivo of Kermartin 2/21/05 . chapter 1
Oh, my God, that was heart-breaking. Poor Peter, who's done such terrible deeds out of such desperate, incurable and, ultimately, hopeless love. And the loss of James, as well as the evil of his actions, are both driving him insane. The grief, the pain, the need for forgiveness and the hunger to be loved are so real that the words almost bleed.

*

Brilliant, brilliant job.
Hiril Moon 5/17/03 . chapter 1
Eargh... Angsty...
harvey-potter 11/4/02 . chapter 1
You are an incredible writer. I aspire to be half of what you are. I absolutely felt every emotion and deepest sensation, be it good or bad, that wormtail was feeling. Such descriptive and powerful writing. Although I don't agree with your reasons as to why he betrayed them all, I absolutely loved this story/rant/verbal marathon. It moved me. Well done, yet again.
Chainlinks 10/25/02 . chapter 1
Lovely, lovely, lovely. It's so great to see a fic that portrays Peter as something other than an evil person who's always been evil, always will be evil, with no love or compassion in his soul. All the words were so pretty, too!
BritaChica 9/17/02 . chapter 1
On of the best Peter-not-compleatly-evil fics I've read.

It was really well written when he kept reapeting the word James in every sentance.

*Puts on favourites list.*
pcg 8/4/02 . chapter 1
...wow. Just...wow.
Destiny and Sincerety 5/28/02 . chapter 1
oh wow, that was ending is soo powerful..
All Mighty Terrestrial 1/24/02 . chapter 1
If I ever doubted that Pettigrew was cowardly and slightly off his rocker, this took it away.
Sara the Green Witch 12/28/01 . chapter 1
*sniff* Okay, sad..sad...sad. *sniff* AAAAAWWW! Almost feel sorry for the littler bugger...No,not really. But ALMOST, so that's very good. Very very good. Love it!
anon 12/15/01 . chapter 1
wow. that was deep. much coolness. _ great!
Michele Lupin 12/15/01 . chapter 1
Wo, that was weird. It was cool but weird. It is nice to see a fic explaining why Petigrew did it. and for the first itme i don't hate that rat like no tomorrow. - but i am sure i will go back to hating him about 10 minutes after reading this... i just don't like him. - Anyway great fic.
Olive 12/15/01 . chapter 1
Wow. :( That's really good and intense. And sad. But that was the point, I guess.
brokenstar1987 12/15/01 . chapter 1
ahh, that was so sweet and sad! *face takes on mournful expression* please write some more! you could do other peoples' ramblings too.
If you think this is a story youve GOT to be kidding 12/15/01 . chapter 1
You... uh... wrote a... SLASH fic about Peter with James? God, I feel sick... this has got to be one of the most disturbing fics I have EVER read in my LIFE... ew, gross...
Myr Halcyon 12/15/01 . chapter 1
wow, i'm very impressed, owari. i know almost everyone's felt like this about someone, but you put it into words so very well...maybe this just hits me because i had a little significant other trouble, but this is very good angst. not cheezy at all. congratulations. (and my sympathies)
16 found: Page 1 2 Next »
Return to Top