Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Melody of a Memory - Page 1 of 9
Crispy Rice
2009-11-06 . chapter 9
So angsty! Just my kind of story!
Violmaster
2009-10-30 . chapter 9
I really enjoy reading this you did a good job discribing Sato. I feel like I can relate to both characters. I really do hope you continue this story as it has just gotten to a part where I feel it needs to be continued :)
Aimi-chan
2009-10-02 . chapter 9
I like the sexual tension that is slowly appearing. I'm really looking forward to the two getting together! And bring back Pikachu, please! -grin-
Kaitlyn
2009-09-30 . chapter 9
I really love this story! A long shishi fic is a rare treat. I started reading this quite a while ago and just checked back to find chapter nine! I quickly gobbled it up and now hunger for more. Keep writing and you will be repaid a hundred fold in form of cookies and hugs. Paid in annual installments over the next five years of course. :p
Mistakesmeanslearning
2009-09-20 . chapter 9
This is quite nice,really.
I don't think I found any spelling errors or anything, so you're a really great at correct writing, that's for sure.
The story is also great! Please continue soon
Kitty-Titty
2009-09-17 . chapter 9
Other than an occasional slip up between "there" and "their" I'm enjoying the story. Interesting premise and you're carrying out realistically and well.

I hope you continue =)
Sin of Pride
2009-09-16 . chapter 9
I like this. I mean, I really enjoy the maturity of the narration, if that makes sense. I can tell that you're the kind of write who can take some overused cliche and make it really work. Not that I'm calling this a cliche.

Actually, this is my first time reading a Shigeru/Satoshi fic. Or even a Pokemon fic, I think. I am extremely glad to have happened upon your fic rather some other poorly written joke. That sounds harsh, I know, but there are a lot of people nowadays who don't take the art of writing seriously.

I'm looking forward to seeing what happen with these two in the future. I like how its so apparent just why Satoshi has never had a steady girlfriend and yet he remains blissfully oblivious without a sudden, dawning realization.

Thank you for this wonderful story. Keep up the writing!
Chocolate-and-Rum
2009-09-15 . chapter 9
Please do write more, I love reading this ^^ and I wouldn't worry about the review thing there could be many reasons for it.
salence
2009-09-15 . chapter 1
I haven't read the story yet (which I hope to soon) but I just want to say a great big THANK YOU for reposting this story! I was seriously bummed out when it was taken down as quality Shishi fanfiction are as rare as master balls. =)
Novawings
2009-09-12 . chapter 9
Hey I just found this fic and really enjoyed it. I'm normally a little hesitant about first person point of view but I think you've made it work really well. I look forward to you posting more.
VickyVicarious
2009-09-10 . chapter 9
This is really excellent. Mature and sweet, and by far the best Pokemon fanfic I've read. Please keep it up.
Fletset
2009-09-08 . chapter 9
You have NO IDEA how glad I am to see this story back up. I still think, as I did the first time I read it, that it's the best fanfic I've ever read.

I still love how it's slow and reserved, how it's so easy to identify myself with the characters...

I know you probably don't want it, but I can't help but comapre this version to the old one. First, I'm glad that you changed that entire name situation - although that bit when Satoshi called Shigeru's home was confusing. I admit, when I started reading I wondered if you changed it, but I just couldn't imagine Julia other than... Julia :)
So, nice excuse for the names then. I hope that for this version you won't change the POVs - as I do recall it bothered me somewhat the last time.

Are the chapters a tad shorter, or is it just me? Also, was Hanako the one who asked Satoshi to welcome Shigeru into his home in the first version? I can't remember.

In the old version I liked how Satoshi was the one to kiss Shigeru first (I'm not mistaken, right?) and I really loved Shigeru's confession then - he told everything (I do recall falling for a particular line: "you asked me who I liked, and the first person I thought about was you". Something like that, right?). I remember connecting it to Satoshi's behaviour when he was sick and afterwards, that he knew Shigeru liked him.
Now it's somehow seems... less believeable, I think, but not less touching.
I am uber-glad that you left that delrious-Satoshi scene - it was my second favorite!

I did like, however, how in this version Satoshi seemed a bit more angry at Shigeru for his behaviour, and Shigeru's confession of gayness this time around was cute, I guess. Kind of fits his cocky character :)
Oh, Satoshi, you're so dense...

I can't wait to see the next chpters - when things get a bit more heated up, if I remember correctly, and I do remember Satoshi crying because he was lonely at soime point...

Anyway, I'd love to see this story updated and finished, I really think it's remarkable.
Palletshipper
2009-09-08 . chapter 9
I luv this story so much, you're such an good writer, I hope SO much that u continue this story soon, an yes, make it long, I hate read only oneshot's, and ur so talented !
KuraiOkamiWralfan
2009-09-01 . chapter 9
...Best 'fic that I've read in years

I love how Sato is beginning to feel for Shigeru, but not exactly realizing it. I find that really awesome.

This is definitely my kind of story.

Keep up the good work.

I can't wait for more XD.
Failisse
2009-08-24 . chapter 9
Ah! Darnit! They almost kissed! It was so close! I'm getting so excited! I can't wait to read more, so please update again soon! I hope you write in a mutual kiss scene soon because I'm going beserks with anxiousness! I really cannot wait to see Satoshi finally admit his feelings! Thanks for the update! Best of luck!

-Failisse
Return to Top