Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Evolution
MarigoldStevens 8/8/11 . chapter 1
YES! I found it! I had read this story a few weeks ago, and then I wanted to reread it, but I couldn't find it! This just made my day(:
aleera 4/26/11 . chapter 1
Very good :)
secondaryonly 5/22/10 . chapter 1
I like how Draco helps her in the end. I thought it was sweet, after all he did.

:]
Noona1 1/22/10 . chapter 1
He is a typical teenage boy in this till the end .. which was a sweet ending
Lydia91 1/7/10 . chapter 1
What I Liked: the simplicity of the language, the episodic structure that hints at a deeper/developing relationship, your characterization of Asteria (also that you spell her name with an "e", it's so much prettier...and correct!)

What I Didn't Like: I don't really agree with your conception of Draco during his first few years at Hogwarts; I feel that as nasty of a boy as he is, he would treat other pureblooded children respectfully (the exception being the Weasleys, of course), especially if his parents know the family. You did a good job of writing this version of him, though, so kudos. :)
Material Girl 6/2/09 . chapter 1
Short and sweet! I can't get enough of Asteria/Draco fiction. It's so interesting to think of how they ended up together, there are so many possibilities since we don't have details!

Though I don't think Lucius Malfoy would have got out of at least some time in Azkaban for all the crimes he committed!
Wackysocks 5/20/09 . chapter 1
BirdG-

As per your profile, I will leave you a constructive review instead of a "oh I like this!" one.

1) I am glad you spell her name with an 'e'. All this 'Astoria' nonsense is sort of driving me nuts.

2) I liked reading about your perception of Draco - how he nasty enough when he was young that he would be rude and bullying to ANY younger student, including students from his own house. That is a side of him that I hadn't thought about before. Very interesting to think about.

3) I like very much how you made simple moments like eating a Chocolate Frog or writing an essay on the Hogwarts grounds come alive. I could easily picture the places in my head, and the people were very much in character. This goes to show that good writers don't need huge exciting events to create a story - something as small as a Potter Stinks badge could be all it takes.

And now, I will tell you that I did like this very much. )

Wackysocks
Return to Top