| Reviews for: To Have You Holding Me in Your Arms |
 Shisoukengo 9/26/05 . chapter 1this was a good fic, it could've been better had you gone into more detail or depth behind the flashback. And if you would've used your spell-checker or read back over it for typo errors, like when you said "except" instead of "accept". Don't worry about it though, we all make mistakes in our fics here and there, just remember that next time. Otherwise though, pretty good SanoxSayo story. |
 Mana Prism 4/14/05 . chapter 1wah! *cries in joy* another sayo fic! yay! you should write more u know...can't wait for another sayo fic... How come lots of people hate her...? she's so sweet... |
 sharingan99-sayo amakusa 6/8/04 . chapter 1 yo! yay! finally! a sanoXsayo fic! as a die-hard fan of the pairing, Sano&Sayo, i'm very glad ot have read your fic! it was great! though, i think the "teddy bear" thingy was a bit off coz in the RK storyline (which was in the late 1800s)teddy bears weren't invented yet. Anyway, it really was cute! n_n oh yeah, i'm also a christian! and we're both asians coz im a filipino! (im from the country, Philippines) oh yeah im proud to say that I LOVE SAYO AMAKUSA |
 Shimizu Hitomi 11/23/03 . chapter 1Sweet. Very cute. The formatting was a bit odd in places, but otherwise it was very well written.
I don't mind Sayo, I don't even mind Sano/Sayo (I think it's cute, and I much prefer Aoshi/Megumi to Sano/Megumi anyway...), it's the fact that the whole Christian arc even exists that bothers me. And I suspect that may be why a lot of people don't like her. The original Rurouni Kenshin manga did not include this arc in it's storyline... The Christian arc was created basically as a filler for the anime, while the animators were waiting for Nobuhiro Watsuki (the original RK creator) to complete the REAL ending to Rurouni Kenshin. Unfortunately, because of the horrible quality of many of the filler episodes, the rating of the show dropped, so Sony (or whatever company was showing it) decided to end the series before they were able to animate Watsuki's ending. Most people found the Christian arc really lame in comparison to the actual ending (the Jinchuu arc in the manga), and so do not consider it canon. In my opinion, the arc itself was not *that* bad... but it had the potential to be a LOT better. And yes, Jinchuu is definitely my preferred ending to RK. When I write my fics, I personally never take the Christian arc into consideration. Most people go by the manga storyline only as well. So that's why Sano/Sayo isn't that popular. |
 Kazie Solo 11/22/03 . chapter 1Yes! Yes! Praise the Lord! Finally, there's another Sano/Sayo fic! *is overjoyed{Yes, I'm a Christian, and yes, I'm a big Sano/Sayo fan... I write fics of them and I built a website!
And that was very well-written too! There's something a bit wrong with the formatting, but other than that I loved this fic! Totally! A really awesome twist to their already awesome story! Though as usual, too bad she had to die. *sobs
Thank you so much for writing this story! *hearts appear on Kaz' eyes* Can we be friends? XD Anyway, write more fics please! More S/S! |
 Gray 6/7/02 . chapter 1So sad...I really hated the fact that they made Sayo die in the series. I mean, I understand why they did it and all, but...well, anyway, this was well-written and it added a certain something to the whole Sano-Sayo thing. Good job! |
 Aeris 5/4/02 . chapter 1 Wow! Great fic! Sad and sweet.. I just love it! I also like Sayo by the way.. I just wish their'd be more Sayo fics out there. |
 Shinchan 1/1/02 . chapter 1 Your fic is pretty well writen. I like your fic. But I HATE HATE HATE HATE that Sayo-slut (no offense to you/Sayo fans, I just can't help it).
She's a selfish bitch who doesn't even understand one bit about Christianity and thinks she's always right. The slut's a blemish to RK!
Oops... sorry, got too far. Your characters are your choice. |
 Peppy Eve 12/27/01 . chapter 1Me too would like to congratulate you on your story! I don't hate Sayo, I actually liked her and I'm not afraid to admit it either!*fushichou's mob turns on Peppy, Peppy though, stands tall"Bring it on, you crazy pple!*screams and clashes are heard
anyway I do hope you'll continue with this, or write more Sano and Sayo fics, because let's face it...the're is a serious lack of them and you are a very good writer, so I hope you'll help solve this problem! You have potential! Keep writing, for I'll be reading!*waves SxS banners(lol sorry, can't help myself, I'm not really a die hard fan, I support them because almost no-one else does, I fight for the lost and onorthodox RK couples!) |
 fushichou 12/24/01 . chapter 1I actually admit I sorta liked Sayo. I don't really get why people don't like her even if they're not big SM fans.*big mob comes with pitchforks* ahhhhh! But anyways, good job! I barely see any fanfics about Sayo and Sano. I'm a Rurouni Kenshin fanfic newbie too! |
 Karina Kineshi 12/24/01 . chapter 1Wow... I admit begrudgingly, I can't stand Sayo, but I was determined not to let that get in the way of reading this fic. Since you said you need some constructive criticism, I'll give you some *smiles* All in all, it was actually very well written! Kudos to you for keeping this diehard SxM fan occupied But there are a couple of nitpicks...
On dialogue, you don't end what they are saying with a period and then put a comma on the outside of the quotation marks."And I don't play with dolls like girls do.",) is not right. To make it better, you can either make it it's own line and get rid of the comma or break it up like this(And I don't play with dolls like girls do," he stated firmly. "I'm a boy, ya' know!
The biggest thing is... teddy bears were "invented" during the presidency of Thedore Roosevelt, I believe it's 1901-1909. Obviously, the RK timeline goes before this, so having them call it a "Teddy" bear is not right with history. They may have had STUFFED bears, but they wouldn't have called them Teddy Bears. Cute idea though! .org/kidscorner/tr_ *sighs* I think that's it... I hope that my comments helped you and that I wasn't too harsh on you If you'll be writing a continuation to this, be sure to email me. I'm actually INTERESTED in where this is going, but I'm not turning on SxM. *smiles* Keep on writing, Rei-san! |
|