 Emily 2009-10-22 . chapter 1 Aw, how cute. : ) |
 RiverOtter1 2009-09-27 . chapter 1Hello!
Ah, a sweet little story that really warms your heart. This story really made my day, and I want to say thank you for writing it. :) I think you caught Elladan, Elrohir and Estel's personalities perfectly, which really made them come alive in my mind. Thanks very much fro writing this, and I look forward to more of you work!
Happy Writing!
-RiverOtter1 |
 Irritable Insanity 2009-08-09 . chapter 1Very nice. Not too long, but long enough to develop the plot nicely. I enjoyed seeing Elladan and Elrohir as very quiet, matured Elves who still have know how to laugh and enjoy some things with Estel. It's hard to write interactions between older and younger character, and I think you hit this on the head as well as their characters.
They were very grim on the battlefield from my understand (and with reason considering what happened to their mother), but I cannot imagine that they were hard-edged all around.
Estel is very child-like and in character as a child. I used to fret about killing things accidentally, and he has that wide-eyed innocence that you tried and succeeded so well at capturing. It's great to see what that hardened old soldier Tolkien presented us would have been like as a little kid. Love the young Estel stuff. Looking at this, I can say that it's a little sad that he must grow up, but he'd never fulfill his destiny otherwise. |
 Ne'ith5 2009-07-15 . chapter 1Perfectly charming story! I'm glad to see you are writing again it was certainly worth the wait. |
 Larner 2009-06-26 . chapter 1I so love this one, Calenlass! And I so look forward to reading more of Apostate's Ruse! |
 TheFightingTemeraire 2009-06-23 . chapter 1That was great! It wasn't bogged down with extra sentiment or anything like that.
It was naturally sweet. I liked it =D |
 asdfjkl; 2009-06-22 . chapter 1 xD |
 Deandra 2009-06-19 . chapter 1Delightful tale, and lovely view of the interaction between brothers. I haven't read many (any?) others dealing with the twins and Estel as a child. Nicely done!
- Deandra |
 Faerthurin 2009-06-16 . chapter 1Aww, sweet! |
 Thorongirl 2009-06-14 . chapter 1Oh, what a splendid little story. You just get me all wistful and nostalgic with a tale like this. Estel is so sweet and the twins -- well, if there are such things as perfect brothers, they fit the bill. Fireflies - beautiful use of imagery. I too have missed your stories. Glad you are back! |
 estelcontar 2009-06-13 . chapter 1I'm glad you're writing again.
This is a most delightful and sweet story. The image of Estel pursuing the fireflies is a very gentle and graceful one. |
 Jedi Sapphire 2009-06-12 . chapter 1I loved this! The image of the twins and Estel and the fireflies was simply adorable.
Great to see an ME-fic from you again. *g* |
 Midnight Promise 2009-06-12 . chapter 1Hey!
Awesome story, I always love how you portray the brotherly love between twins and Estel. (Especially when he is little!) This is a story that I always find to read after a hard day-something good, warming, and just plain awesome. :)
The comparisons you used were well done and fit together perfectly- it was overall a great story.
Hope RL is getting better!
Midnight Promise |
 HT 2009-06-12 . chapter 1 That was so sweet I almost cried! Thank you. |
 Aimme 2009-06-12 . chapter 1Beautiful, Cal, absolutely stunning! I love it!
And of course, even better because it includes the twins as well as little Estel. *huggles the three brothers* :D
-Aimme- |