Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: On Your Other Side - Page 1 of 2
Mariagoner
2009-12-29 . chapter 3
The end of this was very touching... and horray for Lestrade having some sense talked into him as well!
Mariagoner
2009-12-29 . chapter 2
My, it's a wonder Mary isn't more jealous. But I suppose she's just open-minded? ;)
Mariagoner
2009-12-29 . chapter 1
It IS bad-ass and this is very well written, as always! You have Holmes and Watson's frienship down pat. I can't wait to see more of this story.
Orria
2009-10-08 . chapter 5
YEAH! *laughs* oh yep, that's Mrs. Hudson for you. Oh, and her brother is a gay!? Didn't see that one coming.
Awesome story Prodigy, AND I'm hoping to see more of it.
IrregularHonour
2009-09-22 . chapter 1
You were in extreme danger of completely losing my high opinion in this story...

but you didn't. Whew!

You redeemed yourself with ONE line.

"'Watson!' Holmes practically choked."

In case of potentially offending someone, that is all I'm going to say in this review.
koredik
2009-08-16 . chapter 5
Nice chapter and great to see more of Mrs Hudson. I must say I'm a bit (a tiny bit!) disappointed to see such an obvious non-slash chappy. You know it's more fun to tiptoe around the bush :) But all your characters are really lovely. Thanks for your work
koredik
2009-08-16 . chapter 3
:) And a toast for Gregson. I really like the content of Watson's bag too.
koredik
2009-08-16 . chapter 1
Wiggins was great! Honestly, he really won a war!
Vining
2009-07-12 . chapter 5
Well I can't refuse a review request, that was rude of me. I like the attitude you are taking with these vignettes. You are walking a fine line, and doing it wonderfully, IMO. This is crack, but you write it so well that I can visualize all this actually happening. If you come up with more ideas, please continue, these really are a treat to read and explore the H&W friendship in a way that I've not seen before.

And they are flat out hilarious. This is my kind of humor. You put a lot of thought into this and it shows.
Pompey
2009-07-09 . chapter 5
(smothers snickers) Well, yes, Mrs. Hudson language did raise my eyebrow a fraction but actually, as their landlady she has a far simpler way of knowing if men have been having sex in the rooms -- the bed sheets. ;) (That's a small part of what did in Oscar Wilde.)

Holmes and Watson in bed are amusing. Beside, any well-educated person in that time periods knew at least a small bit of French, and to a lesser extent German. (But I love that Holmes called Watson "dear heart!")
reflekshun
2009-07-06 . chapter 5
Comedic and fluffy. Just what I needed to see tonight. I really enjoyed it. Thank you for sharing.
shedoc
2009-07-04 . chapter 5
lets hope she doesn't decide to pour holmes a congac any time soon!!

and i loved the last chapter - sometimes things have to be dark
Pompey
2009-06-29 . chapter 4
There was at one point a slash!fic out there where Holmes is wasted out of his mind and ends up raping Watson (up to that point the sex had been consensual) but the story was taken down by the author YEARS ago . . . say around 2002 or so. So I think it's pretty safe to say yours is presently the only fic where Holmes "deliberately" hurts Watson. (Oh! except for that one scene in KCS's "Broken and Buried" where Holmes tries to hit Watson but is so weak Watson easily deflects it. I'm not sure that counts.)


Anyhoo, I adore the image of Watson upending the brandy all over the couch so Holmes doesn't get an easy-out. At first I thought it seemed like Watson was trying to force Holmes to choose not to indulge but then it made sense: Holmes did promise he would not indulge BEFORE BED and he was about to break that promise. Watson was well within his right to protest that.
shedoc
2009-06-29 . chapter 4
yet another fine chapter - you are spoiling us!! it was definitely worth the wait!

the only thing that really jarred with me was your spelling of the word perjur (from perjury)... and i didn't know how to spell it until i went and looked it up in an actual paper dictionary i keep on my desk for when the class are being pains about their work!!

and the violent outbursts are actually much more likely in your scenario than many other fics - after all if watson had not been in a 'this is a spafe and sleepy area' headspace, which the sitting room was not, holmes would nver have gotten close enoguh to beat him... or thats what i think, anyway...
reflekshun
2009-06-29 . chapter 4
I read your story, and I just loved it. I had been wondering about the line you crossed, and you turned it into an enjoyable story. Please post again soon, and thank you for sharing.
Return to Top