Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Wish - Page 1 of 31
Amethiste
2010-01-06 . chapter 15
Wahh!
I hate sad endings!! :(
I hope Spock and Jim can make up soon. ( Even though they only just had their biggest fight of all time. ;P )
By the way, sad endings aside, I love this story.
:)
Fernsfairie
2010-01-05 . chapter 15
Very good! You should diffidently continue on with this story, I'd love to see what happens next. I loved Spock's mind; that's what I've always imagined he'd have in there... Different hims, representing emotions, and two controlling hims, a Vulcan-half, and a Human-half, arguing.
~Fern Rose
lov2catnap
2010-01-05 . chapter 15
I was so looking forward to T'Prings death... Or at least for heir bond to be severed...
What shal Jim do?!?! When will he see the light? When will Spock admit that he sees Jim as more then just a brother?!?!?
When shall you update the next chapter?!?!!?!??!?!!
Love it!
Timber Delonic
2010-01-03 . chapter 15
You should write the next chapter as soon as possible. I found this story well written. It is an excellent read. Please continue it soon. ^-^
Yana5
2010-01-03 . chapter 15
Spock that was mean
i hope Jim will be ok
Heth
2010-01-02 . chapter 15
Awesome chapter hope this isnt the end of spock and jim forever
Kayzo
2010-01-02 . chapter 15
oh this is so good! I really like you're characterization of both Spock and Kirk and the portrayal of their strenghs and weaknesses in accordance to your plot--a really interesting and enjoyable plot at that.
I really can't wait to see what happens next!
Helen Bache
2010-01-02 . chapter 15
YAY! an UpDate! damn this story is AWESOME!! as you can see from all the stats... :D UpDate soon!
DoctorWhovian
2010-01-02 . chapter 15
I am craving the next chapter. You are just that good.
Marie Vulffe
2010-01-01 . chapter 15
Lovin' this fic. It's an awesome take on one of many 'what-ifs.' Great characterization, great plot.

A few things i wanted to get off my chest before i forget, though: #1, during their 14th/15th years, when they get taken by the Romulans...i don't know if it's because it was 2 in the morning, or something else, but i couldn't really follow what was happening. I got the overall progression of the arc, but...what was up with the ship they were on? Was it a hijacked Starfleet vessel? Were all the nervous/scared crewpeople more kidnapped humans? How did McCoy come to be there, exactly? Just some things that were bothering me.

#2, T'Pring. I thought it was canon that the youngsters are betrothed via their parents, and all that...even if it's not, it still kind of threw me for a loop that she and Spock were bondmates without Jim's - or anyone's - knowing. If you could maybe flesh this part out a little, give us the story on how they became bondmates, and what that means in this particular universe, it would be wonderful.

that's all i can think of, for now. Please, continue with this awesome story! <3 OH. I do hope that once Jim gets to Starfleet (THAT will be an interesting story in and of itself), he and Spock won't be estranged the whole time, up until the Narada Incident. I would love to see them working together from the beginning on thwarting Nero, and how Jim gets to be Captain in this universe. Not to mention...if Amanda still dies, how will Jim react? Surely not as callously as he did originally. I hope.

K, really done this time. XD
Lady Talla-doe
2009-12-30 . chapter 15
-le gasp!-
Oh! Jim's pissed!
I can't beleive you left it at such a cliff hanger- and yet kept with the /exact/ dialogue (alsmost) as the movie! WOW!
I shall wait eagerly on an update!
Lady Talla-doe
2009-12-30 . chapter 12
I should hope ot never meet a person who takes such malicious glee in giving 'the talk' as Bones.
Heh.
cricket5144
2009-12-30 . chapter 15
Your way of writing is very beautiful and magical! It's like reading a good book... I just escape into the sotry, as if I am actually there! Amazing really amazing! Can't waint for the next chapter!
The Foggiest Idea
2009-12-30 . chapter 15
Okay, wow. This was such a great chapter! And the ending made me shudder. :)

Thank you so much for updating! I can't wait for the next instalment!
sernity1806
2009-12-30 . chapter 15
Here is to the new year, hoping you update like right after the new year hits.
Very interesting story, and looking forward to where you take it.
Return to Top