I love it!;; Please keep writing! MORE! MORE!

Whoohoo, this is great! I can't wait to read more! PLEASE POST!

sweet, I love this twist to the story! Can't wait to read the rest!

Hey don't stop just yet - this is very promising. I like the way you're working the alternatives out here and the interaction between the

Rangers' characters is spot on. (Cool horsey descriptions too!)

Looking forward to chapter 4 :)

Great story, original idea and I hope you write more

Ivy

Really good premise...so when does he start becoming Evil? Muahahhaa!

this looks good - i'm wondering how far you're giong to take this, it's always good to see Halbarad in fics - he's not written enough, sadly...

and if you can write her well, don't worry about using Arwen.

keep it up,

aryne *

This looks promising, keep it up.

You just had to get a Robbie Williams quote in there somewhere didn't you?

This is gonna be very good. You write all the characters extremly believably (is that a word?).What more can I say? Please write more.

very well done, Id say. It will be very interesting to see the changes going on while Aragorn is bearing the ring, not Frodo. Please continue! But I need to ask you one question: Why did you choose Arwen to be a part of the Fellowship? I do not know whether it will be important for your story later on, but in the first chapter as I read it, it sounded quite strange to me. First Aragorn wants to go alone to keep his friends out of peril and then he choses his love to go with him...