I adore this so much. You have Sheldon's voice down exactly, which is a rarity in this fandom. Him wanting to get engaged after just seeing Penny's interest? Hilarious and yet SO COMPLETELY SHELDON.

And how Sheldon says he is committed to her. Oh, my heart! <3

Even though the engagement seemed kind of sudden, you explained it so well that I could see canon Sheldon doing the same thing. I enjoyed reading this, thank you.

WHE! This is brilliant!

ACK! Why isn't this a real episode? MAKE IT HAPPEN, PLEASE!

Wow! This had everything i could want in a p/s fic! The journal entries were brilliant, they fit so well with sheldons character and I could totally see him thinking that. Not to mention they were hilarious! Everything was just so perfect; I felt like I might have been reading the script for a new episode. Well done! The only thing wrong with this fic is that it was too short :( I loved it so much I didn't want it to end. I'll defintely be reading this fic again and again :) great work!

Aww, I really love this! It's so good, nice work! :)

That was definitely the longest proposal I've ever witnessed!
A VERY typical Sheldon argument, it was so great that the argument was about her marrying him. haha. Loved it!

Oh! please write more for this pairing, you capture them really well. <3

This was an excellent story. I love how in character Sheldon was.

You did a fantastic job. Can't wait to check out more of your stories. =D

this story kicked **. great job. sheldon and penny were perfect.

I know you said it was only two parts, but I want MORE. I'm glad to know that I'm not the only Penny/Sheldon fan out there. You portrayed Sheldon wonderfully in this, perfectly in character, yet he still managed to capture Penny's heart. I loved how Raj, Howard, and Leonard happened to return to the apartment, the ending was priceless.

Ngahaha! It’s ridiculous how in character Sheldon is here. The whiteboard proposal especially. And Penny's acceptance of said proposal is completely plausible. I heart you for writing these two so well and making me believe that they could fall in love and get engaged in the same day. I wouldn't mind a sequel, then again I'm not a big fan of Leonard's angsting...

All in all- brilliant!

I love your interpretation of Sheldon in this! There’s a very believable battle going on between reason and emotion, spirituality and science. He’s basically thinking with a different head, if you catch my drift (and I’m very sorry if you do)...

It's just nice to see him trying to be human, as scary as it is. Mayhaps he's trying a little TOO hard, what with the engagement ring and all, but he'll get it right in the end, with Penny's help. That's my earnest wish at least. Onto the next!

Fabulous story! Sheldon is completey in character, but still somehow romantic, which doesn't sound possible, but somehow you've made it so.

(I was geekily excited to discover the author of one of my favourite House fics was writing for my new obsession. Yay!)

Cute. Very well written.