 Rominion 2009-10-29 . chapter 1Wow. I love the insight into his character that you can see with the words that he didn't end up including. This is a very well written piece that expresses his feelings exceptionally and keeps very close to his character as introduced in the books. Well done. |
 excessivelyperky 2009-09-30 . chapter 1I hope you can finish this properly--isn't it always Snape's fate to be rejected by those he cares for? At least it is in canon. I hope for better in fanfiction. |
 Little Sev 2009-07-07 . chapter 1I'm not sure whether my reaction is influenced at all by watching the MJ's memorial on tv, but you managed to move me, every time, with your words. Beautiful. |
 Marivan 2009-07-06 . chapter 1I take it from the title, Hermione never actually read the letter. Which is a shame, because you've captured the innermost essence of Severus Snape: the person below the hard exterior and all those sneers. And if you put this letter in the framework of Snape's cannon demise, it makes it even more poignant.
I like how you've put the erasures in parentases, (it makes the letter more human) but when he has crossed out a whole phrase, I might put the whole phrase in one parenthase, instead of each word having seperate parenthases. But it's a minor thing.
Very clever: a flawless execution of a great idea.
Kudos!
~Marivan |
 Valmarien 2009-07-06 . chapter 1What a lovely letter - I enjoyed the Pride and Prejudice quotes and the way you worked them in. Placing alternate phrasings into brackets was a really interesting idea, as well - I like the way it opens up and clarifies the meaning of Severus' thoughts. |
 MistEternal 2009-07-06 . chapter 1This was a lovely, angsty read. I can't help but wonder whether Hermione is feeling as Severus thinks she is or if something else was on her mind when he proposed. Great piece and glad to know you're alive. ;) Cheers. |
 Deeble 2009-07-05 . chapter 1Oh dear indeed. Poor professor.
There's something very Jane Austen in the tone of this letter, and I like that very much. |
 whitehound 2009-07-05 . chapter 1Oh dear - tragic, but very in character, from what we see of his relationship with Lily. |
 diamond-helen 2009-07-05 . chapter 1Strange, but very interesting, i liked it a lot. |
 purplerebecca 2009-07-05 . chapter 1Lovely. |
 duj 2009-07-05 . chapter 1Nice to see you're still alive :))
Poor Snape; he's always been the faithful sort. |
 TresOrleans 2009-07-05 . chapter 1My heart is breaking...Please do not let this be the end, let it be a mistake. Please, please make this right.
Tech note: Delightful composition (as always). I like the sincere urgency of the overall tone. |
 HighOnMyMuse 2009-07-05 . chapter 1 Lovely. I really enjoyed it. |