wonderful fic. loved it so much. Would have liked it much more if you had a beta reader to fix some grammars. (English isn't my first language either so I can understand the difficulty.) Cried little at the end but still good job. You deserve a batch of muffins! :3

this story was beautiful. i give you 1,0,0,0,0, kudos. this was well written and very believable. congrats.

The story was great right to the end but in the end it never adressed if Ororo and Scott were alive in their time.

I love your story so far but I see Gimli may have been abandoned in this chapter just letting you know.

I loved it!
It made me cry...
Very great!

omg i can't stop crying for the life of me this was really really really good story. i'm just sad it over it seem like it could live on forever. I remember reading this story when it first came out and i forgot to get the name of it but i thought it was a good story and so i lost it but now i found it again and i love it. I couldn't stop reading it. I would love to read the "improved longer and illustrated version" of the story. My email is or Thanks very much

oh man that awas a fine story but although scott and jean had to die, it was couldnt be helped. i loved you last part
Years turned into decades. Decades turned into millenniums and slowly history became legend and legend became myth. A fairytale arose from the mist of time, telling about four magical warriors from another place with powers unseen to Middle Earth, a brave leader, a beautiful Goddess, a mighty man-beast with claws of silver and a sorceress tormented by her own powers. It told of the brave sacrifice of the leader of the men of Gondor and of the leader of the strangers. It told of the evil Phoenix, who was as evil as she was beautiful. It told the bittersweet tale of the man-beast and the sorceress who was wedded in love but who had been cursed for their forbidden passion so that they could never touch. It told a tale of an Elven prince and the Goddess, who sacrificed everything to stay with the Elven prince she had come to love. It told of a bloody and terrible war that had given birth to heroes and villains alike and which had given birth to the strongest of loves and the deadliest of sleeps.

oh man i could cry

Beautiful, so sweet! Adding this to my C2!

The focus has too much Legolas, and not enough Logan. Legolas is also way too fast, (I mean, catching arrows...) to be realistic.

great job, i really liked it,(not L/R being married, ew, he's more like a father figure.)

Loved it

:: blinks :: It wasn't mentioned in the movie that Aragorn spent the magority of his childhoold being raised by the elves? I think it was after his mother died or something (his father having already died) I'm surprised it never at least came up in passing.

one of the best fics i have ever read. i read the entire thing in 4 sittings. i couldnt tear myself away for to long because so many questions would race through my head. the only thing i was a little disapointed with was scott and jean dieing. if only because scott and jean are what make classic x-men classic x-men. know what i mean? but yeah i would love to read the new and improved version if ya could email it to me. my email is joesmokes @ msn . com i put spaces because some sites dont allow URL's/Email adresses in reviews and im not sure if this is one of them. thank you agian for sharing such a unique story with me and everyone else here on fanfiction.

u r really talented. i love this story. please email me back if you have any more stories. i would love to read them :) happy holidays

haha they are both the same guy
thays funny i don't care who you are
lj

hahah
i love it its great keep it up