This is tuly the best story there is. It's just like I really imagine them to be.
And ... I seem to be coming back to this one again and again.
It's just so beautiful.
Thank you so much!
I really needed to say this... ;)

Even though I couldn't revew this without mentioning the mistakes in tenses, I must say I really quite enjoyed this story. This was so well in-character it was actually scary - not many MMAD writers actually keep it that way. I could hear them well in the dialogue. Even though it has been said Dumbledore was gay, I would like to believe there was more between him and Minerva, a long lost secret shared between the two of them only.

I really loved the almost stumbling over the leg of the chair. In fact the best M rated scenes are a bit like that. I just loved the part of Minerva comparing herself (or not) with the nun. I loved how in fact she misunderstood him, and how thoughtful he was to ask her that one particular question in that way before the point of no return.

Very well done here. Thank you for sharing.

that was amazing.

just .. amazing.

you have captured them both so perfectly. minerva was strong but on the edge the whole time, daring to love him even though she knew that it would hurt her.

and albus was my hero, i say my because i love him so much ;)

the best story i have read in ages! xx

Wow! This was a fantastic story! Very well written and totally on character. Wow!

Thx for sharing!

So sad, within a few paragraphs I had tears in my eyes. It is the most incredibly moving story, so beautifull.

Oh wow this was really good!

and really sad too.

poor Minerva...and you characterized Dumbledore very well ]

That was beautiful. Dumbledore a mixture of Judas and Jesus at the end there.

That was both an excellent and beautifully written fic. I really love this line: Minerva didn’t move her hand from his chest, unwilling to give up the little metronome to which Albus Dumbledore led his life. You wrote Albus and Minerva very well; I can really see them acting the way they did in this.

thatwas hard. And I don't think I caught everything. But interesting...

wow!I like it very much!Great!

It was only after I submitted my previous review that I realised YOU were the author. Naturally, I never expect anything less than excellence from you, and am pleased to report that I am not disappointed. In fact, I believe I shall have to raise my estimation of your talent. Great job, again, and I'm so glad you wrote this!

Excellent job - angsty but not with the melodramatic "oh-I-can't-go-on-without-him!" feeling that seems so prevalent in those many fics which have sprung up since the movie's release. Thank you so much for an incredibly well-written, plausible story!