Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: I Needed You
szepilona10 3/5/08 . chapter 2
Beautiful and sad story! It brought tears to my eyes!
Doranwen 8/4/03 . chapter 1
He might not have been mentioned in the poem, but he is right above it. Too bad he's the only one listed there that's not in the poem-I've always liked him since a friend put him in her fic-the best Tolkien one I've ever see This one is not too bad.
Lindir 1/3/02 . chapter 2
yeah, i was pretty surprised (and not happy) that tolkien didn't include Halbarad in the poem talking of the fallen in the battle; I was also surprised at how Aragorn didn't even show that much sadness, but oh well...thanks for writing this- I think it portrays their friendship well.
Mel 1/3/02 . chapter 1
Sob. So sweet. Wonderful, fanatastic. I hope Halbarad will be in the third film but I have a very bad feeling. oh and i think you're wrong about nobody ever writing a story about his death, I think someone once wrote it as a chapter to a story.. can't think who. Oh well, your version was brilliant. Well done.
Return to Top