|Reviews for So Much for Secrets|
| LouiseDenise 7/5/12 . chapter 1
I read this weeks ago and thought it was brilliant, and last week when I was on vacation, I suddenly thought about it and realised I HAD TO read it again, and post a review, since it obviously made an impression on me. Slughorn is phenomenal, absolutely brilliantly written, and the awkwardess is... well, apparent is an understatement. I almost had to bury my face in a pillow when I read the second half of it. Well done!
| pot kettle black 4/15/12 . chapter 1
This was excellent, your characters were great, you struck the perfect awkward note, and it was also very funny!
| FireChildSlytherin5 1/14/12 . chapter 1
| Heptagon 9/13/10 . chapter 1
Wonderful story. I always do enjoy reading good stories about Slughorn. And he was very much himself here, bragging with his students, getting enthusiastic and carried away, and then suddenly realizing he might have said a bit too much. Or a lot too much.
Well, I would have expected slightly more (or less) from Severus, he strikes me as a sort of inward suffering outward scowling type. The gasp was fine, but I would have expected him to flee to some dark corner for some private suffering right after that.
But that's just my humble opinion, I did love your story, and Slughorn was perfect.
| Gunther123 5/23/10 . chapter 1
oh god, i can't imagine if this had happened in hbp there goes three chapters of dh. very well written. to be honest i expected snape to kill himself or harry to slap him. ah well. great story
| misundersnape 5/2/10 . chapter 1
Oi - 'awkward' wasn't the word for that...
This was excellent, btw - very well written. And ol Sluggy was perfect!
So, that can't be the end, surely - a sequel? a continuation? Surely one is in the planning... You know, Harry's thoughts... I gotta know, you see...
*puppy dog eyes* Please...?
| David Fishwick 1/30/10 . chapter 1
Excellent and thanks for writing.
| JimandArtie4ever 1/9/10 . chapter 1
A great story. Very well written.
| mAd4H-p 12/27/09 . chapter 1
This was really good, I always wondered why no one ever mentioned that Lily and Sev had been friends.
| Dormantness 11/3/09 . chapter 1
Wonderful...I always wondered what Harry would do if someone let SSLE friendship slip...poor Severus:)
| severus 9/18/09 . chapter 1
please write another chapter please i like this story alot
| kahlen369 8/29/09 . chapter 1
oh! hope you do a sequel! :D Very IC for all of them! I can just picture slughorn doing this.. he does seem the type.. XD Very canon take! You could insert this into that chapter and in wouldnt be out of place.
Hope you do a sequel/second chapter! perhaps of snape's/harry's reaction/POV.
| Moi 8/10/09 . chapter 1
Nice. I wondered why it never happened in the books. I'd be interested in reading about Harry's reaction, if you plan on doing a follow-up piece.