 Love and Rock Music 2009-08-19 . chapter 1Ooh, lovely! I liked this very much. It has a nice, coming-of-age kind of tone. Sweet (as anything with Lucy is), but also weighted with grief and gravity. There's something very intriguing about the Pevensies' early reign. For most of the series, they're grownups that look like children, but here they are children who must suddenly be grown-up. You handle it very well.
I am growing quite fond of your writing! I'm always happy to see your pen name pop up in the archives, and this story stays true to form. My favorite lines were: "You're a queen, Lucy. You decide what you want to do; only Aslan and your conscience can overrule you." and "Would you diminish his sacrifice?" And I loved the cannibalism reference. Great job! |
 ilysia 2009-08-18 . chapter 1Ah, difficult topics, but you handled them very well, and you had Lucy handle them very well, too, if I may say so. The references to the Witch's cruelty were disturbing, but almost fitting, in a way. It seems wrong to sugar-coat her tyranny and, what's more, I can see Jadis doing just what you have her doing. Lucy's emotions were, I thought, very naturally portrayed; always, I think, there's a lingering sense of 'what could I have done' when someone dies before their time, and I expect this would be multiplied in a new monarch. But Aslan's answer is what his answer always is: I never tell what could have been. Bravo. |