Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: An Uncommon Witness - Page 1 of 2
CaptainBillyTheWerewolf
2009-11-24 . chapter 3
This is great. Have you posted this somewhere else? I really want to read the rest.
lifeisacaberet
2009-10-23 . chapter 3
At the risk of being cheesy, I think this fic is the cat's pajamas! I like the concept, it's very creative for a Tutu fic. You obviously did a decent amount of research on the period and I like how you incorporated major historical events and gave the characters different immigrant backgrounds. I felt like it fleshed out the atmosphere of NYC in the 1920's. I also like the storyline, it'll be very exciting to see what happens next. Personally, I prefer the look of a Rolls-Royce in the twenties to a Chrysler, but either way Rue is one classy dame ^_^
Natsuko37
2009-10-21 . chapter 3
Oh, I didn't know Edel meant "gem" in German, I learned something new today! I always thought spelling it Edelle would be prettier. I enjoyed reading this, logging into my e-mail and seeing that this updated was a welcome end to an otherwise horrible day. Sadly, I don't know much about ballet or the 20s so I can't really judge how you've represented them, but I do believe you've woven your words with excellent skill.
BlueForestAngelCat
2009-10-21 . chapter 3
Amazing as always! This story is fantastic! I love it!
I can't stop loling! Lol. Poor Ahiru/Duck...but it's just too priceless! Fakir is absolutely incredible! Fakiru rules!
xxFireWarriorxx
2009-10-21 . chapter 3
AMAZING job! Absolutely perfect and flawless! I loved especially the part with Rue and Ahiru. I felt like you captured their personalities and communication wonderfully. And then that scene when Mytho and Rue first met was also very beautiful. All in all, awesome work! The Fakir/Ahiru tidbit also never ceases to make me smile. :)
Full Shadow Alchemist
2009-10-21 . chapter 3
Yep, I defiently love this story! The progress made is resonable, the AU is believable and all of the characters and their relationships are amazing. I especially enjoyed Rue and Ahiru's interaction. They just think they'll never see each other again, when in reality, a Romeo-Juliet friendship is developing! Wee~

Defiantly, its love.
Moon Shadow Magic
2009-10-21 . chapter 3
Still enjoying this! Nice reflection on the history of entertainment (usually left to Singing in the Rain, which focuses on the speaking voice--"an' I cayunt stan'im.") And on pointe shoes, my knowledge of which comes from a documentary probably on "Dance in America" decades ago.

I noticed one slightly awkward change of tense ("To this day Rue does not..." could be "did not," although that will sound a bit strange next to "to this day.") The only other thing I saw was "kennel" for "kettle."

Don't rush, make the next one good too... I promise I'll go away from the computer for breaks while I wait.
James Birdsong
2009-09-18 . chapter 2
You did okay. :)
Maiden of the Heavens
2009-09-18 . chapter 2
This was a fantastic start,please update soon!
-MOTH
BlueForestAngelCat
2009-09-17 . chapter 2
Great job, I don't know much about legal procedures, but it sounded good to me!
P.S.: does Corvo mean Raven? I'm curious.
xxFireWarriorxx
2009-09-16 . chapter 2
Wow, awesome job with this! The plot is really picking up now. :D I loved the interaction between Fakir and Ahiru - they were very much in character - and that last part with Mytho and Rue was very nicely executed. The description was especially amazing. :D

Update soon please!
BlueForestAngelCat
2009-09-16 . chapter 1
One chapter, and I'm hooked! LOL. This is absolutly amazing so far, you can count on me to be waiting for the next chapter!
Mikure
2009-09-09 . chapter 1
What a treat to read another story written by you! I felt like this chapter was too short though (then again, I love long stories, so that could just be me) and moved too quickly. But hey, I look forward to reading more!
LunaSphere
2009-09-09 . chapter 1
I saw this on lj too but I was too frazzled to leave a real review. Of the PT 20's AU your fanart spawned, I think I've enjoyed this one the most because it has the clearest conception of a larger, long-term plot. You keep both Duck and Fakir so in-character in this (and evil!Mythos too--I loved the principe thing, it is at once so mobster and so PT!). What I love about this is Duck's first vision of Mythos is so different than in canon and yet, the variation has lovely echoes of canon in it.
Willowleaf2560
2009-09-08 . chapter 1
Mytho in the mob? Wouldn't've seen that one coming. And yet, strangely cool. It's original, I noticed barely any grammar or spelling issues, it's original, I love your writing style, and did I mention how usual a plot like this is? If you haven't noticed, I like rare ideas. Congrads, you get an A+ in my book. This looks promising, and I'm excited to see the next chapter.
Return to Top