 dogtanian 2009-11-07 . chapter 6ah, i really liked that story, a good mix of humour and seriousness. and that times square kiss was just great! |
 SMACkedHuddy 2009-10-10 . chapter 6Extremely well written! Love the ending, too.
Any chance for an epilogue or a sequel? |
 Kara Leyna 2009-09-25 . chapter 6i like it alot! i just read the last three chapters and it was very good!! Out of couriousity is Stella and Mac's kid gonna have a godparent, or godparents? And if so who? |
 lily moonlight 2009-09-25 . chapter 6I loved this. I loved it a lot. Thanks for writing and posting this, and a small request, please write another story for Mac and Stella soon! It's been a huge pleasure to read; beautifully and intelligently written and completely true to the characters I love. The conclusion was just perfect, I could picture the scene clearly, and then that description of Lindsay was wonderful. |
 lily moonlight 2009-09-25 . chapter 5Oh wow. what can I say? I adored this chapter! I just love how you write these characters to the bone, exposed and vulnerable with all their complications and frailties. It was a tremendous piece of writing. And I loved how it concluded; from emotional nakedness to physical nakedness and the beauty of that. Brilliant. |
 lily moonlight 2009-09-25 . chapter 4Oh, much as I love Hawkes, he couldn't have chosen a worse moment! Sorry I'm a little behind, but I've read all the last few chapters, so am now reviewing, though they might be a little short. I hope the last ones have been okay. This was a wonderful chapter, and I liked how you wrote Lindsay very much, and how it was her who comforted Stella. Wonderful line about bloody shirts and bleeding hearts. |
 csi-ncis 2009-09-24 . chapter 6That was an awesome ending to this story! haha I love that they didn't come out and say it, they were hoping their detectives had figured it out. You put in another not twist but danger when Stella was pushed down the stairs. Great Job. |
 FoxPhile 2009-09-24 . chapter 6I have thoroughly enjoyed this, and I'm sorry I haven't reviewed before.
After chapter one I thought, this is going to be cheesy, but cute. Cute it has been, but also intense and riveting. I like the tension you maintained between Stella and Mac - both assuming the other was only in it for the almost-clinical purpose of conceiving a child while both were secretly harboring their true feelings. It made me particularly laugh in the last chapter at Mac's "You’re supposed to be detectives!" He should talk - he can't even tell when a woman he's with so many hours in the day is in love with him? Sheesh.
But I digress.
I enjoyed how you brought out Mac's emotions and passion. I've always suspected that a lot of fire was hidden beneath that so-cool exterior. And it only makes sense that the loss of Clare would cause him to bury it so deep that many would never suspect it exists. Only Stella could bring that out and I love how you let us see how that could happen. And when Mac finally allowed his true passions and sense of fun to come out - Watch Out! I mean, sex in the park? And he would have done the Liberty statue too, if Stella had let him.
The last chapter was so touching. Poor Mac is still so painfully shy, and such a contrast to flamboyant, outgoing Stella. The complement each other.
And finally, thank you for the little tribute to Lindsay at the end. I know many fans don't like the character - feel she has no substance. But I agree with you. There's spunk and fire under that quiet, bland exterior. Have you seen the Season 6 premiere? Don't mess with Montana - she'll kick your butt! |
 Azurite 2009-09-24 . chapter 6D'aw. I guess I didn't pay attention that it was complete? Regardless, I'm glad Mac and Stella both got the "ending" (or rather, "the beginning") they were hoping for. I also loved Lindsay's characterization in this: I could see her barely suppressing a squeal at Stella's behavior, Adam making a guess, and everyone else just Not Getting It. Downright adorable and had me giggling in fits. I think I spotted one more Britishism (rubbish) in Chapter 5 or something, but it wasn't enough to jar me out of the story for more than a split second.
Thank you for writing this--it was well-characterized, aptly-timed for a dramatic, emotional opener to Season 6, and a sweet SMacked story. Good work! |
 Azurite 2009-09-24 . chapter 3Okay, I've got to review at this point even though I know there's more. I'm grateful for this because I feel you capture the Stella x Mac dynamic amazingly well, and Stella's POV is great: realistic but sassy, somehow undeniably Stella. I only caught two instances of Britishness (?) that threw me out of that point-of-view, and that was the use of "bloody" (in reference to something not at a crime scene) and "Sod off," which...well, in New York, you just don't say. Other than those two things, I thought it was fantastic and I'm eager to read more and see how this very original plotline turns out! I loved Stella's chat with Flack, it made me laugh out loud. Nice work! |
 Synnove 2009-09-23 . chapter 6What a beautiful ending. I loved how Lindsay really pulled them together - I've always pictured her as a SMacker. You wrote these guys beautifully. I especially enjoyed the scene with the young teenagers and SMacked scaring them off. You did Mac and Stella proud :D
Keep writing - I definitely am looking forward to reading more of your work. |
 Lola-Ladybug13 2009-09-23 . chapter 6What a great ending... I especially loved the last paragraph about Lindsay, because she's my favorite charcater and she is a tough one, she's been through so much and she's still amazing... great story! i loved it! =] |
 csi-ncis 2009-09-23 . chapter 5Beautiful :) That is what I'm talking about, now that they have stripped each other emotionally, whats next? I love that they both used the other! |
 Lola-Ladybug13 2009-09-23 . chapter 5oh... so wonderful! i'm so happy they finally told each other! great job! |
 csi kane 2009-09-23 . chapter 5yey glad they back together woo sexy time yey |