Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Witch's Apprentice - Page 1 of 15
Phantom-Akiko
2010-01-06 . chapter 23
This one's very nice as well^^ So happy to see, that Hakuba gets a bigger role by now x3 I like him xD
Phantom-Akiko
2010-01-06 . chapter 22
Sorry, I couldn't comment and read this chapter before^^° I have been away most of the time...and other things happened... u.u° However, I really liked this chapter, had a lot to laugh and it was thrilling as well. You get really good^^ Go on like this ^o^
Darkfire kitten
2010-01-05 . chapter 23
Hey there! I'm glad you're back. Hope your "lazy" holiday was at least enjoyable.

And about the joke thing, it was sort of, "what the hell" when I read the review reply, but then I got to that part in the chapter and thought "Oh yeah! That joke. Duh!" Forehead slap followed immediately by much giggling and grinning.

As for the note deductions, I understood the reasoning, but I got lost in the explanation, if that makes any sense to you.

And one little lesson in grammar for this chapter, and no worries for this one as it is a very common mistake. Towards the end, Kaito and Conan on the phone. "Once You've past 50[percent]" You used past, where you should have used passed(past tense of the verb 'to pass')

Funny thing is, if you had written you're, then that would have made your use of "past" a preposition and therefore correct. Past can also be used as an adjective(past lives), an adverb(walking past), or a noun(past, present, future).

Anyway, looking forward to this next heist. And I have faith that you'll catch up, you did it once, you can do it again.

DfK out.
Pandakitty
2010-01-05 . chapter 23
Hur, I wanna know NOW! AND YAY! I got it RIGHT! ... It's funny cuz I still have those Christmas cookies my mum gave me in front of my computer :'D

"Whether it would be before or after Kuroba’s funeral, Conan couldn’t be sure."
F, you'd better hope it's BEFORE. LONG before!! Silly Conan!

"Bobbing up and down at his side, Conan scowled as the large hat covered his eyes."
BTW, what's the point of the HAT?!

"“Yes.” Conan replied. “Among…other things.”"
What kind of... "other things"? harr harr, I know, I know, stuff in the movies an' stuff, whatever. *pout*

"“Kuroba, you’re acting quite fishy to me.”

In the instant the word ‘fishy’ floated about the air, Kuroba’s feet held their position: one on the ground and one in midair, halfway through a step."
LOLOLOLOLOL. Oh Conan/Kiro, you never fail to amuse me x3

"“Not to mention none of the months even have a ‘k’ in them.”"
Actually, in Japanese 'September' is "Kyuugatsu", so it's STARTS with a 'k'! hur

"Little know to Saguru, behind him such abuse had just taken shape in the form of a fist connecting with a small skull."
That should be "little KNOWN" right? :3

"Solving the riddles far quickly than any other child, he definitely had talent."
And that should "far MORE quickly" or "far quicker"

"‘Wait…’ a memory crawled up from the back of his skull. ‘…resembles…Kuroba…? …Didn’t someone else-’"
OHOHO!! It that what I think I see thar?! :'D

"“I suppose the heists are the closest thing I have to bonding with my dad.”"
Daw :')

I wish school made me write faster... but it seems to deter me from writing because of the stupid writing contract thing *rage*
LOOKING FORWARD TO MORE AS ALWAYS... although I can't wait 'til chapter 28 the most! That is of course, if you do what you said you would do. OH, I CAN THINK OF SO MANY CUTE THINGS THAT COULD HAPPEN IN THAT SITUATION~ *punted*
Pretztailfan95
2010-01-05 . chapter 23
R! *punts Kaito to the river Styx so that Komachi can assume he wants to commit suicide and so Sikieiki will judge him and send him to Hell* WROAR!

HAKUBA! FOR ONCE, I'LL LIKE YOU EVEN JUST A LITTLE BIT IF YOU GET RID OF KAITO FOR ME! DX
Oh wait nevermind. YOU CAN BOTH FEEL THE WRATH OF SIKIEIKI!*punts both idiots*

Poor Conan...*sobs*

Oh yeah, I forgot to mention something about the last chapter. My jaw literally dropped when Aoko thought Kaito Kid might be pregnant. It stayed that way for 30 seconds or something.

I'm surprised too...well, he's sure to be punted more~ ESPECIALLY AFTER THIS!

Oh~! That reminds me, I automatically agreed with my friend when she said Heiji looked hot when I first showed him to her. Ever since, I've been a spazztastic fan~

I GOT IT FOR CHRISTMAS! D:< YES, BE JEALOUS!

I thought it died a long time ago. O_o *hides Phoenix Downs*

lolz your thoughts of the word 'punt' remind me of my thoughts about 'e'. DaGras keeps typing that whenever I reveal a line of one of my upcoming chapters. I keep imagining this high-pitched squeaky "e"! XD So cute~

Madness?
THIS
IS
SPARTA!

Bah I was trying to think of one. D: Well, I'll give you the name of a character that should appear soon in one of my fics~ Magi-chan~ It literally means "strange witch".
Such a shame because she eventually-shot-
Mel72000
2010-01-05 . chapter 23
Thank you for this chapter.
Then, Today and the next days I have my exams, I am in the s*...
I wish you a happy new year and continue in this way for your story !
Marie Ravenclaw
2010-01-04 . chapter 23
Oh no!! I was downstairs watching a movie and didn't get to read this chapter when it first came out!

but this chapter! so much to talk about and so little brain power!! (I'm still on break for this week...don't go back til the 11th...but I can't get in my dorm til the 10th...isn't that lame?) but Kai-chan! and he didn't freak at the mention of fish! and Kuba-kun! and...drat..my brain is still rebooting...a oneshot yesterday broke it and it was doing good til this chapter...but now...my brain needs a reboot cause of the awesomeness!
DetectiveConanFan13
2009-12-31 . chapter 22
I wasn't able to read it at Christmas because my parents changed plans without telling me! I am now living with my grandparents who have the slowest internet in the world! When it works that is! Rawr!! I got to read it on New Year's Eve though! Happy New Year!!

Kaito's song at the beginning was great! I sang it... And then burst out laughing!
Is Kaito's singing worse than Shinichi's? I know that is a big accomplishment and all but if Conan is complaining with his own voice, Kaito must be pretty bad!

"...pregnant."
I agree with Conan and Akako! *Falls Off Bed With Thud* Ow. *Continues Laughing*

An actual elf? Well, with magic existing and all I can't say I am surprised! =) I love it how she thought Conan-kun was an elf! Hear us well, there is no magic behind him being small. Just a bunch of really shady bad guys after immortality and power. You know, the usual!

That bit at the end with the "Merry Christmas...dad," was so nice! I love it! It is the first year Kaito-kun knew he was still around and... Aw! That was just really nice!

Are you going to write about Kaitou Kid and Kid Kaitou in the next chapter? I love them! =) I still laugh about the fish thing in the first heist though! Too bad Kaito-kun had to get revenge! *Laughs*

I am excited for the next chapter and hope you update before I go back to the Exceedingly Slow Internet of Doom. ESID for short!

Thank you for the chapter and I hope you update soon! Before ESID time but I think I mentioned that already! Once again, Happy New Year!

~J. DCF

This is a really long review! My longest ever! Love the story! =)
Miyanoai
2009-12-27 . chapter 22
Well, I dont't think it really matters whether it's good or bad. Lol, It's interesting imagining just saying the name Hoseki randomly and the room going silent. (And of course I'd give you credit ^^ although, I'm not sure I'll actually say it in public...hmm)

Omg, this is probably one of my favorite chapters yet. Omg! Mistletoe!! Yay ConanXAi! Thank you Kaito! XDXD
"Heiji had to wonder what Kudo had done to deserve that" *punts Heiji* Who said it was a bad thing! lol

I CRACKED UP at the beginning scene and am STILL laughing at Conan's random love outburts (and their reactions ^^) and that scene with Kaito and his dad was just so sweet!! XD Heh, an elf...that was a actually really clever, and most likely believable.

One other thing, there was something in the last chap I wanted to mention but forgot:
"Call me Volley" "No, Mr Volley is Mr Volley!" lol, now why does that sound familiar? ^^

Thanks again for this chap and a merry christmas and happy new year to you too. ^^
Pandakitty
2009-12-25 . chapter 22
That was flashback was... what? WHAT?! I wanna know DD:

LOL THOSE SONGS. I finally know what Conan's version is... cuz when you sang it I could hardly understand half the words D>

"Slightly irritated, Hattori couldn’t help but exclaim, “He’s back! The closed off Kudo we all know and – t’ a certain, not awkward extent – love!”"
F, you love him in a kinda awkward way, Heiji, you just won't admit it x3 *shot shot shot*

"“Kiss…kiss…kiss, kiss, kiss, kiss…” People kept joining in."
KISS KISS KISS KISS, YES NO CUTE <3

*sniffle* that ending, was ADORABLE <3 Poor Kaito </3 I love this chapter > "sama" addresses the person's authority and... well just listen to me!
But I must say I don't like it when people use Japanese in their fanfics other than the honourifics... just sayin'...

UH THE REFERENCE TO ANOTHER ANIMU IS THE AFFECTION RING THING FROM INUYASHA? I think lol, if that's not it then I have no idea >>

MERRY CHRISTMAS KIRO-CHAN~ Although in one hour it won't be anymore OTL. I'LL GET YOUR PRESENT(s?) AS SOON AS I CAN D: I'll look in Winterpeg while I'm there :)

It took me so long to read this chapter since supper and going to see the lights in Breadenbury interrupted half way through and the fact that it's so long didn't help D< BUT I LOVED THIS CHAPTER AND WILL FOREVER <3 IT TOTES MADE MAH DAY <3 whatever is left of it OTL IT MADE MY YEAR THEN. EVEN MORE THAN LINEBECK BEING IN SPIRIT TRACKS... okay I'm getting off topic here..

I'm not looking forward to doing that LA thing D: LOL NOT HELPING

SEE YOU SOMETIME SOON HOPEFULLY.
Darkfire Kitten
2009-12-25 . chapter 22
Hey! An awesome Christmas special. Loved it very much. Funny, I didn't realize what you were talking about with "that joke" until I was reading it. WooHoo!! Really did enjoy how that played out. Love yah for that.

Also, I noticed a couple typos. Come on Ran, -Hope- in.

From the entrance of the town it had appeared -quiet- flat.
That quite vs quiet seems to be very common. I've seen it at least a few times before.

And as for your challeng of sorts in the author's notes, The only possible reference I notices was "The mystery of the moving bag" but that's not animu, it's A video game, and possibly a manga after that, though I wouldn't know if it actually happens there. Kingdom Hearts 2. The only one of the series I've actually had the chance to play through to date.

Speaking of Kingdom hearts, there's a pretty good Crossover between it and DC/MK I know of. Promenade by, I think it was Ocianne, either way, it's in the DC/KH crossovers section. Anyway, I was thinking, if you haven't already, you should offer this story as a universe for Kaito and Saguru to visit in the sequal "The Way Home". I think it would be a pretty cool one to see.

So, thank-you for a wonderful and well-worth-the-wait Christmas chapter.

A Very Merry Christmas to you, even though I am posting this a smidge late.

DfK out.
The Pen in Penguin
2009-12-25 . chapter 22
“Kaitou Kid!
Kaitou Kid!
Kaitou Kid my **!
Kid can’t steal,
Since he squeals,
At the sight of bass."

Oh, god, I laughed... *glomps KID* Don't worry, Kaito... I still love you... *snickers* XD
Pretztailfan95
2009-12-25 . chapter 22
I CAN'T BELIEVE I JUST READ THAT! DX THAT WAS AWFUL KAITO!! *punts Kaito three times. One for the prank, one for the revenge, and one just because I hate him* AND YOU! *punts five times. One for the creepy Conan, one for the ConanAi scene, one for Kaito's prank, one for making Conan get kidnapped, and one for this whole chapter*

Heiji-sama is awesome~

HOLY CRAP THAT WAS FREAKY!! Conan...grah that was just creepy. A lovey-dovey Conan is creepy no matter what! Even if he was clinging to Heiji-sama's leg in what would look like an adorable manner, it was creepy!! Even though I want to see those two bond together, THAT WAS CREEPY! *is scarred for life* Yes, scar, not scare. That was scarier than that picture of a man dressed up as Misty from Pokemon! AND HE HAD HAIRY LEGS! *punts elf for making Conan creepy*

*grumble grumble* I dun like ConanAi...I would punt her, but I just finished watching movie 3 in English and I LOVE her voice. I can send you the same message I sent Chiyu-chan if you wanna know about my presents and stuffs~ BUT MAKE SURE YOU REPLY!

YES IT DOES! I PUNT HARD! AND BESIDES, AFTER BEING PUNTED THAT MANY TIMES, YOU SHOULD ALMOST BE DEAD!! ...I've punted a lot of people. O_o

YEAH YOU BETTER USE THAT LIST!! D:< Glad it's awesome~

HIATUS!?!?!? *punts* I DON'T CARE IF IT'S FOR A GOOD REASON, I WANNA SEE WHAT HAPPENS NEXT! *punts for making this a filler chapter* I IS ANGRY! NOW I HAVE TO WAIT FOR CHIYU-CHAN'S "Two Bites" FIC AND THE NEXT CHAPTER OF YOUR FIC!

...A lot of my favorite fics got updated today. O_o Er...yesterday?
Mel72000
2009-12-25 . chapter 22
Merry christmas, sonoci !
And thank you for your present, this wonderful chapter !
I wait the next chapter impatiently, thank you again !
Sabel
2009-12-24 . chapter 22
Clever clever~
Noeru=Noel?
Good job
^^
(if there were more references, I haven't caught them)
Return to Top