Reviews for Where the Shadows Lie

Reviews For: Where the Shadows Lie - Reviews: Page 1 of 15

Mortimier 2008-02-19 ch 28,	abusethis is an amazing story! Really in the spirit and style of the real thing and when you read it I really feel that this is EXACTLY as canon would have evolved. Good job and really really tnx
Hikagi 2007-12-13 ch 27,	abuseI have not had the pleasure of reading Lord of the Rings fanfiction for quite some time. It sent shivers up and down my spine because the story was so different than the original, yet very believable in its own right. The style and voice you've incorporated is also very different to what many other people use on FFN, so it was a good change and break from the other fics I've been reading. And I do love Boromir having the chance to stick around.
Dorette 2007-07-15 ch 28, anon.	abuseThis was a wonderful story! Great characterisation and you really made me love Gandalf. I'm impressed with how you've portrayed everything realistically. (As realistic as it could be, that is. ;D). I've read the story non-stop and I really like it. Well done!
Valinor Sunset 2007-06-06 ch 13,	abuseThis story is incredible. Though I didn't read every word of it since I didn't have the time, it really got my heart pumping. Amazing piece of writing. Gandalf forever!
gee0 2006-10-24 ch 18,	abusecool
Elwing-Evenstar 2006-08-27 ch 8,	abuseWOW!! This is a really neat story, and I look forward to reading the rest! Interesting perspective of the "Sauron got the Ring back" plot idea! I have to say that I, too, have imagined the Three Rings to have genders, and some kind of lives of their own, though my idea was quite different than yours, I think. I love the way this story is going!! I'll be sure to read more of it soon! :D
Lilandriel 2006-06-08 ch 27,	abuseWOW! this is astounding! truely fantastic piece of work xx t'is long, but i'm so glad i read it. well worth the read! congrats! off to try and find your book, now! xx
GabrielSilk 2006-04-01 ch 27,	abuseWoot! Great story! ^_^ Poor old Sam. PLEASE write lots more like this! Although not the same as it would get boring then. Namarie; elen sila lumenn' omentiuelvo!
dreamspell 2005-04-09 ch 5, anon.	abuseI found this story through me loving your Unbroken Universe, am in the fifth chapter, and can't hold back my review any longer. This story is making me cry my heart out. It's perfect. And I can't believe how you've made your style similiar to Tolkien and not have it sound absolutely ridiculous. Congratulations!
KissTheRainGirl12489 2004-08-10 ch 27,	abuseI imagine this was a quite complicating stoy to write and I know I could not have written it eventhough this thought of what would happen if Sauron did regain the ring has entered my mind more than once.You did an excellent job on this and I appluad you.Eventhough some parts were boring they had to be written or this story would turn out to be missing important information.
Jo Quinn Undomiel 2004-05-14 ch 1,	abuseThe story is awesome, and I enjoy reading all, well, most all "Lord of the Rings" fanfiction. Keep up the good work.
hairy_hen 2004-03-30 ch 28, anon.	abuseWow! What an awesome story. I am truly amazed. I'm glad you have such a high opinion of Gandalf to think that he could have ended it that way. I've always had fun imagining what could have happened if Frodo had chosen differently, and here is a great story on that subject that still manages to end happily, for the most part. Well done!
ZeldaStrife 2004-02-12 ch 3,	abuseOh, my... This chapter brought tears to my eyes. How could you do that to Sam... I love your writing style! You get right down to the point, but don't go incredibly into detail. And yet, you do go into detail! (Does that even make sense?) Namarie!
ZeldaStrife 2004-02-12 ch 1,	abuseWow! I am quite impressed! You've already hooked me woth the first chapter. Just so you know, it usually takes about two and a half to do that (except for Cassia!). Well, must see what other mistakes Frodo makes. Onward, to Minas Tirith! Namarie!
Rebecca Starflower 2004-01-17 ch 2,	abusewow, this looks utterly incredible. i've had an idea like this myself, but i don't think i could have executed it as well as you have. your description is fantastic, and you're obviously a book lover, cuz this is very canonical in terms of facts such as ringbearers and valar etc. anyways, i'm gonna get on and read the rest.

Return to Top