|Reviews for My Fairytale|
| LarrythePlatypus 4/9/13 . chapter 81
Loved this, I read it all of the time, despite it's length.
Earlier though, when Eldarion mentioned his age to Eowyn, she said "You are young" although according to the timelines in the Appendices she is supposed to be 22 and Eomer 26
Anywho... apart from that your story is almost without fault, I love this.
| alexiana75 3/17/13 . chapter 6
No, don't worry, the switches between POV-s are very good
| alexiana75 3/17/13 . chapter 1
that was a very interesting beginning and not too hard to read. I certainly like it. Good work
| TheAbster 3/2/13 . chapter 81
I loved this! I wish you all the best for writing more amazing fanfictions, as this had the perfect amount of everything in it
| mrstomdaley1996 2/11/13 . chapter 81
This story was absolutely amazing. You had me laughing, crying, angry, happy, everything. I didnt want it to end. I loved it so much, and am so glad Estel got to be with Legolas in the end!
| Felicia 11/26/12 . chapter 81
So I think it's been almost 2 years since you published this... And I must say that words cannot describe how beautiful this story is! About a week ago I felt the need to read something original and romantic, and I luckily came across this! I couldn't tear my eyes away... Every chapter, I needed to know what happens next! Quite honestly for the sake of my school work, it's a good thing I finished!
While I'm on the topic of ending, I'd have to say this is one of the most painfully perfect endings I have ever read... Which is a good thing! It would have been too easy to have Estel choose to remain with Legolas. But this was perfect. I definitely yearned for them to be reunited in some way and I was hoping that maybe Legolas would wait for her, but that wouldn't be possible.
Anyways, I hope you're still writing, if not a published author by now, and I'll definitely have to look into your other stories... After this semester is over, of course! :)
All the best,
Felicia (if you do see this and have twitter you can find me there- Felicia_Stacey)
| Guest 11/8/12 . chapter 81
I'm just going to write a review for the whole story here. I thought this was absolutely amazing. I loved your portrayal of the characters, and how true you were to the book, especially in your usage of quotes. The premise of the story is wonderful, too. This, as fanficton, is utterly perfect. It holds true to the characters, but adds a different spin. I loved it. I couldn't stop reading it. And I know have to do the chemistry homework I've been neglecting in order to read this. :) Thank you for this.
| Through Jaded Eyes 5/23/12 . chapter 81
W o w. This story is so GOOD! Like, completely amazing. Everything about it is fantastic; the way you portray the characters, making the plotline realistic, developing the characters personalities - especially the OC's - making Haldir live (yay!) and Boromir for a while longer, and I especially love how obvious it is that you've done your Lord of the Rings research on everything to make sure all the histories are right.
Obviously there are a few typos here and there but no one's perfect right? Wouldn't want you being a Mary Sue, which Estel is NOT may I add, which I must deeply thank you for. So refreshing! :L
All in all, an absolute gem of a story. Thankyou so much for writing it!
| gginsc 1/17/12 . chapter 81
I truly enjoyed your story. I'm a bit confused about Haldir Cirdanion. How did he get to be in the line of kings? Wasn't Cirdan the name of Tinuviel's ex lover? Did they have a child?
| AyameRose 11/10/11 . chapter 80
didnt you say there would be one more chapter?... either way this works... but i do wish you would add another chapter so that the story doesnt end so bittersweetly... other than that i have nothing bad to say about this story
| Anarriima-illuvatar 9/26/11 . chapter 81
I simply cannot fanthom why there aren't more reviews for this story.
Not only was it extremely well written, but the plotline was amazing.
I read it all in one evening! (Thanks a lot for distracting me from all my university papers...)
I'm still a bit baffled at the ending. The fact that they had to be separated for so long and that Legolas had trouble regonizing her and even resisted at first... Broke my heart!
Keep up the writing! You are very talented!
| Laeriel Oranor 8/1/11 . chapter 81
I read this story in 2 days. I normally take a little longer in reading, especially something this long. But it was well written and had a unique storyline. I must admit it was a little confusing at first, what with all the names in the beginning being the same as the canon characters. And I found it weird to read some of the exact wording Tolkien used in his books, but I thoroughly enjoyed every sentence. The characters were well rounded and Estel was not a "Mary-sue". She had faults and vulnerabilities, strengths and weaknesses. I was glad to see that she had a quality that many authors tend to leave out when creating an O/C.
Now having said all this, I think that were you to go back through the story, you would find some minor errors in the grammar and construction of some of your sentences. Some words are missing or you have the wrong tense. Nothing that is glaringly wrong. Just some things that make it more difficult to read. Even if you do not edit this fiction, I think it is one of the better stories I have read in a long time. And I am very well read.
I have read hundreds of LOTR fiction...and I have now added this to my favorites not only here on but also on my own computer.
Congratulations on a job well done!
| Firestorm Nauralagos 7/31/11 . chapter 1
I just remembered something from the books that applies to your fic, and it's bugging me: Estel is what Aragorn was called when he lived in Rivendell. A.k.a. Estel is a boy's name. Just saying. You could try using EstelA, with an A, since that's the feminine version of the name Estel. With that covered, the story sounds good so far (I've only read chapter 1 so far) and I will definatly continue to read it. [ ::: ] Ice cream sandwich for a good first chapter! :)
| karnna 7/31/11 . chapter 81
hi! I'm currently reading this one! so far so good!
| Astrid Oak Moon 6/14/11 . chapter 81
Very well written through and through. I absolutely love this story. You really should write your own novels; you definitely have the skill.